Standing at the edge of our city, a man could feel that we had made this place of streets and dwellings in the stillness of the desert, and that we had done a brave thing... Or a man could feel that we had made this city in the desert and that it was a fake thing and that our lives were empty lives, and that we were the contemporaries of the jack rabbits.
About this quote
- What does it mean?
- The quote contrasts two perspectives on human achievement in a harsh environment: one sees it as brave creation, the other as empty imitation.
- In plain terms
- Building a city in the desert can feel like a brave act or a hollow mistake.
- What can you take from it?
- Our sense of progress depends on whether we value creation or authenticity.
Where it applies
Putting it to work
Questions to consider
- Does building something new always add value?
- How do you define a meaningful life?
Another view
The quote assumes a binary choice between bravery and emptiness that may not capture nuanced realities.
More from William Saroyan
The role of art is to make a world which can be inhabited.
Permalink to quote #25 I don't think my writing is sentimental, although it is a very sentimental thing to be a human being.
Permalink to quote #27 Everybody has to die, but I always believed an exception would be made in my case. Now what?
Permalink to quote #24
Related quotes
One cannot create an art that speaks to me when one has nothing to say.
Andre MalrauxAndre Malraux quote #10 God made the country, and man made the town.
William CowperWilliam Cowper quote #64 I never give my work to somebody else and say, 'What do you think about that?' I just don't trust anybody. If I think it's funny, or if I think it's silly, I s…
Charles M. SchulzCharles M. Schulz quote #3