If the enemy tortures, it defines their moral evil and all intelligence gleaned from such coercion is self-evidently false propaganda. If we do it, it isn't wrong, and it leads to good intelligence. Got that? And these people have the gall to describe their ideological opponents as moral relativists.
About this quote
- What does it mean?
- Some claim torture by enemies is false propaganda, while torture by us is valid.
- In plain terms
- People say enemy torture is wrong, but our torture is acceptable.
- What can you take from it?
- Double standards exist in judging torture by who commits it.
Where it applies
Putting it to work
Questions to consider
- Who is right to torture?
- Does context justify torture?
Another view
Context may justify different views on coercion.
More from Andrew Sullivan
Is it not a rather fantastic historical irony that the torture techniques that the North Vietnamese used against McCain that forced him to offer a videotaped f…
Permalink to quote #23 If you suspend the Geneva Conventions, give the green light to anything that will get intelligence, round up thousands all over the globe with reckless disrega…
Permalink to quote #22 When Bush says that Abu Ghraib was the work of a few, he forgot to mention that he was one of them.
Permalink to quote #21
Related quotes
Experienced military and intelligence professionals know that torture, in addition to being illegal and immoral, is an unreliable means of extracting informati…
Harry E. SoysterHarry E. Soyster quote #1 What al Qaeda and Saddam Hussein did was an extreme form of sadistic torture, the kind that psychopaths enjoy and inflict. But that does not make, say, freezin…
Andrew SullivanAndrew Sullivan quote #9 Torture gives false information. And the worst scenarios that tortured detainees coughed up - many of them completely innocent, remember - may well have come t…
Andrew SullivanAndrew Sullivan quote #17