Several dozen journals now exist that print only verse. They don't publish literary reviews, just page after page of freshly minted poems. The heart sinks to see so many poems crammed so tightly together, like downcast immigrants in steerage. One can easily miss a radiant poem amid the many lackluster ones. It takes tremendous effort to read these small magazines with openness and attention. Few people bother, generally not even the magazines' contributors. The indifference to poetry in the mass media has created a monster of the opposite kind - journals that love poetry not wisely but too well.
About this quote
- What does it mean?
- Too many poetry journals publish low-quality work, making it hard to find good poems.
- In plain terms
- Excessive publishing dilutes quality and discourages readers.
- What can you take from it?
- Quantity in journals harms poetry readership.
Where it applies
Putting it to work
Questions to consider
- Where is good poetry hidden?
- How should journals prioritize quality?
Another view
Niche journals serve specific communities effectively.
More from Dana Gioia
Forty years ago, when Dylan Thomas read, he spent half the program reciting other poets' work. Hardly a self-effacing man, he was nevertheless humble before hi…
Permalink to quote #30 Poets serious about making careers in institutions understand that the criteria for success are primarily quantitative. They must publish as much as possible a…
Permalink to quote #32 Even if great poetry continues to be written, it has retreated from the center of literary life. Though supported by a loyal coterie, poetry has lost the confi…
Permalink to quote #29
Related quotes
England has the most sordid literary scene I've ever seen. They all meet in the same pub. This guy's writing a foreword for this person. They all have to give …
William S. BurroughsWilliam S. Burroughs quote #3 As I've often said, I'm a fan of hard SF. No, it's more like I am addicted to it, even the stepped-on 20 times and cut with powered milk and rat-poison sort of…
James NicollJames Nicoll quote #23 I personally regret the shift in literary study from reading primary texts to reading critical and theoretical texts. The major problem today among students is…
Dana GioiaDana Gioia quote #39