The major difference between Astaire and Kelly is a difference, not of talent or technique, but of levels of sophistication. On the face of it, Kelly looks the more sophisticated. Where Kelly has ideas, Astaire has dance steps. Where Kelly has smartly tailored, dramatically apt Comden and Green scripts, Astaire in the Thirties made do with formulas derived from nineteenth-century French Farce. But the Kelly film is no longer a dance film. It's a story film with dances, as distinguished from a dance film with a story. When Fred and Ginger go into their dance, you see it as a distinct formal entity, even if it's been elaborately built up to in the script. In a Kelly film, the plot action and the musical set pieces preserve a smooth community of high spirits, so that the pressure in a dance number will often seem too low, the dance itself plebeian or folksy in order to 'match up' with the rest of the picture.
About this quote
- What does it mean?
- This compares two dancers by focusing on story versus pure dance.
- In plain terms
- Kelly focuses on story while Astaire focuses on steps.
- What can you take from it?
- Different artists prioritize different elements.
Where it applies
Putting it to work
Questions to consider
- Does story matter in dance?
- What makes a great performance?
Another view
It simplifies complex artistic careers into a binary distinction.
More from Fred Astaire
Fred taught me a step because I said I can't let this experience be over without my learning something. He taught me the most wonderful Fred Astaire-like step,…
Permalink to quote #64 I suspect it is this Camelot view that leads Miss Croce to be rather unfair to Gene Kelly...I should say the difference starts with their bodies. If you compar…
Permalink to quote #66 The fact that Fred and I were in no way similar - nor were we the best male dancers around never occurred to the public or the journalists who wrote about us..…
Permalink to quote #63
Related quotes
In a statement Dobson announced he supported 'Mel Gibson and his film, The Passion of the Christ, saying Gibson's anti-Semitic remarks had nothing to do with '…
James DobsonJames Dobson quote #10 Some of the acting is better than the film deserves. Make that all of the acting. Actually, the film stock itself is better than the film deserves. You know wh…
Roger EbertRoger Ebert quote #32 It was on tiny wheels with a mount for the camera that put the lens about two feet above the ground. On it rode the camera operator and the assistant who chang…
Fred AstaireFred Astaire quote #41