Skip to content
quotesby

Fred taught me a step because I said I can't let this experience be over without my learning something. He taught me the most wonderful Fred Astaire-like step, with an umbrella. It was a complete throwaway; it was almost invisible. It was in the way he walked. As he moved along, he bounced the umbrella on the floor to the beat and then he grabbed it. It was effortless and invisible. As a matter of fact, a few years later I was photographing Gene Kelly and told him that Fred Astaire had taught me this trick with an umbrella. And Kelly said, 'Oh I'll teach you one,' and he did, and the two tricks with the umbrella in some way define the difference between Fred Astaire and Gene Kelly, and, in my view, demonstrate who is the greater of the two artists. With Gene Kelly, he threw the umbrella way up into the air, and then he moved to catch it, very slowly, grabbing it behind his back. It was a big, grandstand play, about nothing.

Fred Astaire#64

DancePerformanceFilmComparisonArtStyleArtistryTechnique

About this quote

What does it mean?
The speaker compares Fred Astaire's effortless, invisible umbrella trick with Gene Kelly's dramatic, athletic move to argue Astaire was the greater artist.
In plain terms
Astaire's subtle movements showed more artistry than Kelly's showy stunts.
What can you take from it?
Subtlety and effortlessness can define true artistic greatness more than visible difficulty.

Where it applies

  • analyzing performances
  • learning skills
  • evaluating artists

Putting it to work

  • focus on effortless execution
  • study subtle details

Questions to consider

  • What makes a performance truly great?
  • Is visibility necessary for impact?

Another view

Subjective taste might favor Kelly's energy over Astaire's subtlety.

More from Fred Astaire

  1. The fact that Fred and I were in no way similar - nor were we the best male dancers around never occurred to the public or the journalists who wrote about us..…

    Permalink to quote #63
  2. The major difference between Astaire and Kelly is a difference, not of talent or technique, but of levels of sophistication. On the face of it, Kelly looks the…

    Permalink to quote #65
  3. Me? I play Gene Kelly...It's a guy who produces, directs, sings, and dances. who else could it be but Kelly.?

    Permalink to quote #62

Related quotes

  1. 'I merely leap and pause.'

    Vaslav NijinskyVaslav Nijinsky quote #1
  2. People call me an over-actor, people who say this might call Van Gogh an over- painter.

    Jim CarreyJim Carrey quote #1
  3. The notes I handle no better than many pianists. But the pauses between the notes - ah, that is where the art resides.

    Artur SchnabelArtur Schnabel quote #2