Skip to content
quotesby

About this quote

What does it mean?
The author admires Whitman's mind but finds it troubling to admit similarity to a man he considers a scoundrel.
In plain terms
I like Whitman's mind but he is a scoundrel.
What can you take from it?
Acknowledge flaws in those you admire.

Where it applies

  • literary criticism
  • personal reflection
  • evaluating mentors

Putting it to work

  • critique openly
  • separate work from person

Questions to consider

  • Who do you admire despite flaws?
  • How do you balance critique and respect?

Another view

Calling Whitman a scoundrel reflects subjective bias rather than objective fact.

More from Gerard Manley Hopkins

  1. I hold with the old-fashioned criticism that Browning is not really a poet, that he has all the gifts but the one needful and the pearls without the string; ra…

    Permalink to quote #13
  2. By the by, if the English race had done nothing else, yet if they left the world the notion of a gentleman, they would have done a great service to mankind.

    Permalink to quote #15
  3. Religion, you know, enters very deep; in reality it is the deepest impression I have in speaking to people, that they are or that they are not of my religion.

    Permalink to quote #12

Related quotes

  1. Sometimes. Sometimes when I've gone out and murdered somebody I go and confess and stuff. And then God loves me again.

    Tom ArayaTom Araya quote #1
  2. Without books, God is silent, justice dormant, natural science at a stand, philosophy lame, letters dumb, and all things involved in darkness.

    Thomas V. BartholinThomas V. Bartholin quote #1
  3. The poet:who is the legislator of generations and the moral instructor of the world.

    William GodwinWilliam Godwin quote #2