It is madness to attempt to hold. In the first place the troops cannot do it and in the second place if they do not retreat they will be destroyed. I repeat that this order be rescinded or that you find someone else.
About this quote
- What does it mean?
- Holding a position is militarily impossible for the troops and will lead to their destruction if they do not retreat.
- In plain terms
- Do not order the troops to hold because they cannot do it and will be destroyed.
- What can you take from it?
- Avoid giving orders that guarantee failure or destruction.
Where it applies
Putting it to work
Questions to consider
- When is holding a position worth the cost of destruction?
- How should a commander balance orders with reality?
Another view
Retreating without a clear plan can also lead to loss of territory or morale.
More from Gerd von Rundstedt
We are in no position to withstand a prolonged static war. Wherever the allies concentrate their forces they will break through. For us there can be no questio…
Permalink to quote #2 The vast-ness of Russia devours us.
Permalink to quote #4 The morale of the troops taking part was astonishingly high at the start of the offensive. They really believed victory was possible - unlike the higher comman…
Permalink to quote #1
Related quotes
The Egyptian army concentrations in the Sinai approaches do not prove that Nasser was really about to attack us. We must be honest with ourselves. We decided t…
Menachem BeginMenachem Begin quote #1 I tried at that time to relieve the Sixth Army, of which I was supreme commander, above Paulus, by counterattacks - but it was not possible. I gave the order f…
Erich von MansteinErich von Manstein quote #2 For he who fights and runs away May live to fight another day; But he who is in battle slain Can never rise and fight again.
Oliver GoldsmithOliver Goldsmith quote #7