Skip to content
quotesby

But on what basis should the three branches of government be divided? It came down to two dueling ideas: Madison's proposal of an executive, judicial and legislative branch, and Georgia's Joseph Morton's proposal to dole out power according to, 'The presence, forbearance, rectictude and largeosity of one's 'Plums and Carrot'.' After much deliberation, it was decided Madison's proposal would be accepted, Morton only relenting after the Constitutional Convention agreed to proclaim him 'impressive.'

Jon Stewart#56

PoliticsHistoryPolicyAbsurdityLogic

About this quote

What does it mean?
The quote contrasts a serious political proposal with a ridiculous nonsensical one.
In plain terms
It compares a real plan to a fake one based on vegetables.
What can you take from it?
Serious governance relies on clear ideas, not nonsense.

Where it applies

  • debate
  • policy making
  • education

Putting it to work

  • argument
  • lesson

Questions to consider

  • What makes an idea valid?
  • How do we spot nonsense in policy?

Another view

It makes light of the constitutional process which was highly serious.

More from Jon Stewart

  1. Through most of colonial history, inhabitants of the 13 colonies were loyal subjects of the British crown - resourceful, dedicated and as the Third Duchess of …

    Permalink to quote #55
  2. By far the most revolutionary aspect of this new position [of the presidency] would be who could hold it. The short answer: just about anyone. By placing no ex…

    Permalink to quote #57
  3. 30 AD: Death penalty debate heats up after controversial execution of alleged 'Son of God'.

    Permalink to quote #54

Related quotes

  1. The AEC of course has a logical explanation for this absurd situtation...Their regulations say that secret information may be given to a foreigner only when th…

    Freeman DysonFreeman Dyson quote #45
  2. If one rejects laissez faire on account of mans fallibility and moral weakness, one must for the same reason also reject every kind of government action. -- Pl…

    Ludwig von MisesLudwig von Mises quote #1
  3. American militarism today is an unintended byproduct of the reaction to the 1960s and Vietnam.

    Andrew BacevichAndrew Bacevich quote #1