By far the most revolutionary aspect of this new position [of the presidency] would be who could hold it. The short answer: just about anyone. By placing no explicit race, gender, or religious requirements on the presidency, the Founders opened the door the a true meritocracy. Why no women, blacks, or non-Christians have answered the founders' challenge is a mystery, though most indications point to some inherent genetic flaw. (William Howard Taft came closest, having what most observers agreed were boobs.)
About this quote
- What does it mean?
- Stewart satirizes the Founders' ideal of meritocracy by highlighting the historical exclusion of women and minorities, suggesting a cynical view on progress.
- In plain terms
- The presidency has no legal barriers, yet true equality has been slow to arrive.
- What can you take from it?
- Legal equality does not guarantee social progress.
Where it applies
Putting it to work
Questions to consider
- How has the definition of meritocracy changed?
- What barriers still exist today?
Another view
The quote relies on sarcasm that may obscure genuine historical context.
More from Jon Stewart
But on what basis should the three branches of government be divided? It came down to two dueling ideas: Madison's proposal of an executive, judicial and legis…
Permalink to quote #56 If the presidency is the head of the American body politic, Congress is its gastrointestinal tract. Its vast and convoluted inner workings may be mysterious an…
Permalink to quote #58 Through most of colonial history, inhabitants of the 13 colonies were loyal subjects of the British crown - resourceful, dedicated and as the Third Duchess of …
Permalink to quote #55
Related quotes
Senator, some of us strongly believe that Americans are the last people that can go around the world preaching morality. What we are doing to the blacks in Afr…
Pik BothaPik Botha quote #2 Maryam Namazie personifies the gulf between liberal apologists and those who really want equality.
Nick CohenNick Cohen quote #4 The entire trend of development is towards abolition of coercive domination of one part of society over another.
Vladimir LeninVladimir Lenin quote #5