The use of criticism, in periodical writing, is to sift, not to stamp a work.
About this quote
- What does it mean?
- Criticism in periodicals should separate good from bad, not simply condemn a work.
- In plain terms
- Use criticism to evaluate, not just to attack.
- What can you take from it?
- Critique constructively, focusing on discernment.
Where it applies
Putting it to work
Questions to consider
- When is harsh criticism justified?
- How can you balance critique and respect?
Another view
It may undervalue the role of strong condemnation in exposing harmful ideas.
More from Margaret Fuller
Were the destiny of woman thus exactly marked out, did she invariably retain the shelter of a parent's or guardian's roof till she married, did marriage give h…
Permalink to quote #9 Genius will live and thrive without training, but it does not the less reward the watering-pot and pruning-knife.
Permalink to quote #11 Let no one dare to call another mad who is not himself willing to rank in the same class for every perversion and fault of judgment. Let no one dare aid in pun…
Permalink to quote #8
Related quotes
Simon Amstell: So Penny, you used to do a fashion column for the Daily Mail, didn't you? Penny Smith: Yes I've done many strange things in my time. Simon Amste…
Simon AmstellSimon Amstell quote #6 Dr. Kettle was wont to say that Seneca writes as a Boare does pisse, scilicet by jirkes.
John AubreyJohn Aubrey quote #7 The Times is speechless and takes three columns to express its speechlessness.
Winston ChurchillWinston Churchill quote #180