Skip to content
quotesby

[Q: Zionism=racism?] It's necessary, first of all, to distinguish between Zionism and the practices of the State of Israel. The practices are undoubtedly racist. As for Zionism as such, a more accurate charge would be that it was colonialist, in some ways the last episode of old-fashioned European colonialism. But even that somewhat overstates, because the ideology covered a lot of ground, as nationalist ideologies commonly do. And in this case, as in all, there are particularities to consider. That aside, the condemnation of the policies of Israel as racist, while correct, reeks of hypocrisy. Simply look at the practices of those who are issuing the charges.

Noam Chomsky#144

PoliticsChomskyHistoryColonialismRacism

About this quote

What does it mean?
Zionism is better described as colonialist than racist, though critics may be hypocritical if their own states practice similar policies.
In plain terms
Zionism is more colonial than racist, but accusers should check their own countries.
What can you take from it?
Ideologies and state practices should be distinguished carefully.

Where it applies

  • policy debates
  • identity politics
  • historical analysis

Putting it to work

  • distinguish ideology from practice
  • critique hypocrisy
  • analyze nationalism

Questions to consider

  • Can nationalism be colonial?
  • Is hypocrisy relevant to truth?

Another view

Many argue Zionism is inherently racist regardless of state practices.

More from Noam Chomsky

  1. The Oslo agreements did represent a shift in U.S.-Israeli policy. Both states had by then come to recognize that it is a mistake to use the Israel Defense Forc…

    Permalink to quote #143
  2. [Israel's military occupation is] in gross violation of international law and has been from the outset. And that much, at least, is fully recognized, even by t…

    Permalink to quote #145
  3. Israel is an embattled country. They rely very heavily on U.S. support. So they have developed a very sophisticated system of propaganda. They don't call it pr…

    Permalink to quote #142

Related quotes

  1. Senator, some of us strongly believe that Americans are the last people that can go around the world preaching morality. What we are doing to the blacks in Afr…

    Pik BothaPik Botha quote #2
  2. What is the true and original root of Dutch aversion to British rule? It is the abiding fear and hatred of the movement that seeks to place the native on a lev…

    Winston ChurchillWinston Churchill quote #15
  3. The Oslo agreements did represent a shift in U.S.-Israeli policy. Both states had by then come to recognize that it is a mistake to use the Israel Defense Forc…

    Noam ChomskyNoam Chomsky quote #143