Skip to content
quotesby

The US and Israel have demanded further that Palestinians not only recognize Israel's rights as a state in the international system, but that they also recognize Israel's abstract 'right to exist,' a concept that has no place in international law or diplomacy, and a right claimed by no one. In effect, the US and Israel are demanding that Palestinians not only recognize Israel in the normal fashion of interstate relations, but also formally accept the legitimacy of their expulsion from their own land. They cannot be expected to accept that, just as Mexico does not grant the US the 'right to exist' on half of Mexico's territory, gained by conquest.

Noam Chomsky#148

PoliticsChomskyIsraelLawDiplomacyPalestineInternational law

About this quote

What does it mean?
Demanding Palestinians recognize Israel's abstract right to exist is an unreasonable diplomatic prerequisite rooted in their expulsion.
In plain terms
Palestinians should not have to accept their own expulsion as a condition for diplomacy.
What can you take from it?
Diplomatic demands should not require accepting injustice.

Where it applies

  • peace negotiations
  • diplomatic talks
  • academic study

Putting it to work

  • critique diplomatic demands
  • study international law
  • promote fair negotiation

Questions to consider

  • What makes a right valid?
  • How do we negotiate unequal power?

Another view

Mutual recognition is often seen as essential for stable state relations.

More from Noam Chomsky

  1. Before there were any suicide bombers, it was also reported by the same sources that Saddam Hussein was giving $10,000 to the families of anyone who was killed…

    Permalink to quote #147
  2. The whole question of recognizing the right of a state to exist was invented solely for Israel. People, on the other hand, have a right to exist. So the people…

    Permalink to quote #149
  3. [Q: do you think the Palestinian suicide bombers are freedom fighters or terrorists?] They're terrorists - they're both, actually. They're trying to fight for …

    Permalink to quote #146

Related quotes

  1. [Israel's military occupation is] in gross violation of international law and has been from the outset. And that much, at least, is fully recognized, even by t…

    Noam ChomskyNoam Chomsky quote #145
  2. The Oslo agreements did represent a shift in U.S.-Israeli policy. Both states had by then come to recognize that it is a mistake to use the Israel Defense Forc…

    Noam ChomskyNoam Chomsky quote #143
  3. Time has shown how illusory are alliances of great powers so far as the maintenance of peace is concerned. In considering the use of international force to sec…

    Charles Evans HughesCharles Evans Hughes quote #14