The question of whether a computer is playing chess, or doing long division, or translating Chinese, is like the question of whether robots can murder or airplanes can fly -- or people; after all, the 'flight' of the Olympic long jump champion is only an order of magnitude short of that of the chicken champion (so I'm told). These are questions of decision, not fact; decision as to whether to adopt a certain metaphoric extension of common usage.
About this quote
- What does it mean?
- Chomsky suggests that labeling machine behaviors as human-like (like playing chess) is a metaphorical choice, not an objective fact.
- In plain terms
- Calling a computer playing chess is just a metaphor, like saying a chicken flies like a human.
- What can you take from it?
- Language about AI often relies on metaphor, not technical reality.
Where it applies
Putting it to work
Questions to consider
- When does metaphor become literal truth in tech?
- Does the label change the machine's function?
Another view
It ignores emergent capabilities that may genuinely mirror human cognitive processes.
More from Noam Chomsky
Say, take Rachel Corrie, local young woman, she was extremely courageous. She's a martyr for peace and justice. We happened to kill her too, even if we don't l…
Permalink to quote #199 A lot of sophistication has been developed about the utilization of machines for complex purposes, and it doesn't make sense not to use it if you can think of …
Permalink to quote #201 The past month was the 10th anniversary of the massacres in Rwanda, and there was much soul-searching about our failure to do anything about them. So headlines…
Permalink to quote #198
Related quotes
From then on, when anything went wrong with a computer, we said it had bugs in it.
Grace HopperGrace Hopper quote #1 She behaves with all the sensitivity of a sex-starved boa constrictor
Lord StratfordLord Stratford quote #1 No sense in no sense innocence of what of not and what of delight. In no sense innocence in no sense and what in delight and not, in no sense innocence in no s…
Gertrude SteinGertrude Stein quote #3