Skip to content
quotesby

[Chomsky's work was] subjected to an ongoing and intense scrutiny for any literal errors or bases of vulnerability, a scrutiny from which establishment experts are entirely free. This search was perhaps more intense in the United States and among its allies in the late 1970s and early 1980s, with a growing body of hard-liners anxious to overcome the Vietnam syndrome, revitalize the arms race, strengthen support for Israel's rejectionism and policy of force and involve the United States in more aggressive actions towards the Soviet bloc and Third World. [...] The Cambodia and Faurisson disputes imposed a serious personal cost on Chomsky. He put up a diligent defence against the attacks and charges against him, answering virtually every letter and written criticism that came to his attention. He wrote many hundreds of letters to correspondents and editors on these topics, along with numerous articles, and answered many phone enquiries and queries in interviews. The intellectual and moral drain was severe. It is an astonishing fact, however, that he was able to weather these storms with his energies, morale, sense of humour and vigour and integrity of his political writings virtually intact. --Edward S. Herman, In Otero (ed.), Noam Chomsky: Critical Assessments (Vol. III), 1994 [194]

Noam Chomsky#213

PoliticsPowerCriticismDefense

About this quote

What does it mean?
The text describes the intense scrutiny Chomsky faced compared to establishment experts and his diligent defense against personal attacks.
In plain terms
Chomsky faced much more scrutiny than experts and defended himself vigorously against attacks.
What can you take from it?
Critics often face disproportionate scrutiny and must defend themselves diligently.

Where it applies

  • political debate
  • media criticism
  • activism

Putting it to work

  • prepare for criticism
  • document your work

Questions to consider

  • How do you respond to unfair attacks?
  • Who faces scrutiny and who doesn't?

Another view

Scrutiny can sometimes be warranted by error.

More from Noam Chomsky

  1. Chomsky proceeds on the almost unthinkably subversive assumption that the United States should be judged by the same standards that it preaches (often at gunpo…

    Permalink to quote #212
  2. Those who challenge the 'Right to Lie', as Chomsky describes it, can expect to be met with vilification and distortion. Such vilification campaigns succeed by …

    Permalink to quote #214
  3. The major international campaign orchestrated against Chomsky on completely false pretexts was only part - though perhaps a crucial part - of the ambitious cam…

    Permalink to quote #211

Related quotes

  1. I think governments are the cancer of civilization.

    Chuck DChuck D quote #2
  2. Government is good at one thing: It knows how to break your legs, hand you a crutch, and say, 'See, if it weren't for the government, you wouldn't be able to w…

    Harry BrowneHarry Browne quote #2
  3. 'Men in authority will always think that criticism of their policies is dangerous. They will always equate their policies with patriotism, and find criticism s…

    Henry Steele CommagerHenry Steele Commager quote #2