Quote #218

Noam Chomsky, who is an inexhaustible fount of anticommunist caricatures, offers this comment about Leninism: 'Western and also Third World intellectuals were attracted to the Bolshevik counterrevolution because Leninism is, after all, a doctrine that says that the radical intelligentsia have a right to take state power and to run their countries by force, and that is an idea which is rather appealing to intellectuals.' Here Chomsky fashions an image of power-hungry Leninists, villains seeking not the revolutionary means to fight injustice but power for power's sake. When it comes to Red-bashing, some of the best and brightest on the Left sound not much better than the worst on the Right. [...] According to Noam Chomsky, communism 'was a monstrosity,' and 'the collapse of tyranny' in Eastern Europe and Russia is 'an occasion for rejoicing for anyone who values freedom and human dignity.' I treasure freedom and human dignity yet find no occasion for rejoicing. The postcommunist societies do not represent a net gain for such values. If anything, the breakup of the communist states has brought a colossal victory for global capitalism and imperialism, with its correlative increase in human misery, and a historic setback for revolutionary liberation struggles everywhere. --Michael Parenti, Blackshirts and Reds, 1997 [199]

More from Noam Chomsky

  1. Unlike many leftists of his generation, Chomsky never flirted with movements or organizations that were later revealed to be totalitarian, …
  2. ...the problem lies in Chomsky's description of Serb atrocities as 'quite real' and 'often ghastly'. 'Quite real ' is a cop-out for very re…
  3. Chomsky's truly great contribution to the struggle for human freedom is that he has taken what we have been persuaded to believe is an insa…
  4. There's a humbling insight into the US pretension of occupying the moral high ground in Chomsky's work. Part of what he's saying is true. O…
  5. His focus, almost exclusively, has been on U.S. foreign policy, a narrowness that would exert a conservative influence even for a radical t…
  6. Even a quarter of the evidence he had compiled would have been enough to convince me. I used to wonder why he needed to do so much work. Bu…
  7. Those who challenge the 'Right to Lie', as Chomsky describes it, can expect to be met with vilification and distortion. Such vilification c…
  8. Regarding his personal character traits the most outstanding is that he is absolutely faithful, which is something very few people possess.…

All Noam Chomsky quotes