He seems both wholly cynical about the purposes of those in power, and wholly unforgiving. Those who direct American policy - and, by implication, those who direct the policy of any state - are allowed no regrets, no morals, no feelings, and when they change their policies they appear to do so for entirely Machiavellian reasons. Chomsky has little interest in the question of 'good in bad' - of how there can be good behaviour in the context of bad policies - and seems to deny the complexity of human affairs... --Martin Woollacott, January 14, 1989 [211]
About this quote
- What does it mean?
- Chomsky is seen as cynical about power, forgiving no morals to policymakers, and denying human complexity.
- In plain terms
- He judges leaders harshly without seeing their nuanced motives.
- What can you take from it?
- Power analysis can ignore human complexity and moral nuance.
Where it applies
Putting it to work
Questions to consider
- Does Chomsky simplify too much?
- Is cynicism necessary for critique?
Another view
It overlooks the possibility that simplicity aids clear moral stance.
More from Noam Chomsky
Marxist intellectuals can and do convince themselves to subordinate mind and ethics to a larger goal or distant cause that frequently slips out of sight. Anarc…
Permalink to quote #229 [Noam Chomsky is] so far out on the lunatic fringe that even the sensible things he has to say are lost. --David Rieff, August 4, 1991 [212]
Permalink to quote #231 The three paragraphs of Mr. Chomsky to which I have referred constitute less than five percent of his article. I do not know if the level of veracity which he …
Permalink to quote #228
Related quotes
Here's a man who says that Washington is incurably sinful but offers no, there's no complexity, no problem, no moral dilemmas in the book. Everything really th…
Noam ChomskyNoam Chomsky quote #249 The ideal of Morality has no more dangerous rival than the ideal of highest Strength, of most powerful life; which also has been named (very falsely as it was …
NovalisNovalis quote #67 Sneering critics like Noam Chomsky, who condemn the executioners of thousands only in passing, would not hesitate to honour the vengeful feelings of Palestinia…
Noam ChomskyNoam Chomsky quote #236