Chomsky might object that to knowingly place the life of a child in jeopardy is unacceptable in any case, but clearly this is not a principle we can follow. The makers of roller coasters know, for instance, that despite rigorous safety precautions, sometime, somewhere, a child will be killed by one of their contraptions. Makers of automobiles know this as well. So do makers of hockey sticks, baseball bats, plastic bags, swimming pools, chain-link fences, or nearly anything else that could conceivably contribute to the death of a child. There is a reason we do not refer to the inevitable deaths of children on our ski slopes as 'skiing atrocities.' But you would not know this from reading Chomsky. For him, intentions do not seem to matter. Body count is all. --Sam Harris, The End of Faith, 2005 [225]
About this quote
- What does it mean?
- The author argues Chomsky prioritizes body counts over intentions, comparing unavoidable accidents to atrocities to illustrate this point.
- In plain terms
- Chomsky focuses on death counts regardless of intention or intent.
- What can you take from it?
- Intentions matter when evaluating harm and responsibility.
Where it applies
Putting it to work
Questions to consider
- Do intentions mitigate harm?
- How do we judge negligence?
Another view
Intentions are not always clear or relevant in outcomes.
More from Noam Chomsky
PUH-LEEAAZE! Chomsky did not write that Faurisson was a Nazi sympathizer whose right to free speech needed to be defended on Voltairean principles. Chomsky wro…
Permalink to quote #243 Israeli musician, a pro-Palestinian activist at London University, says that burning of synagogues is 'a rational act' in opposition to Israel. What is that? R…
Permalink to quote #245 Noam Chomsky's idea that Bill Clinton's missile strike on a pharmaceutical plant in Sudan was worse than '9/11' is plain silly. --Ian Buruma, May 1, 2003 [223]
Permalink to quote #242
Related quotes
The highest morality may prove also to be the highest wisdom when the half-told story comes to be finished.
Arthur Conan DoyleArthur Conan Doyle quote #1 The liar's punishment is, not in the least that he is not believed, but that he cannot believe any one else.
George Bernard ShawGeorge Bernard Shaw quote #1 Aggression unopposed becomes a contagious disease.
Jimmy CarterJimmy Carter quote #2