The most striking fact is how consistently people with anything at all to say about language feel the need to strike some attitude for or against Chomsky's ideas. It's a big problem. --David Pesetsky, November 1995 [271]
About this quote
- What does it mean?
- People in linguistics feel compelled to take a side regarding Chomsky's ideas, creating unnecessary division.
- In plain terms
- Linguists feel forced to either agree or disagree with Chomsky.
- What can you take from it?
- Avoid making every theory a personal stance.
Where it applies
Putting it to work
Questions to consider
- Why do some ideas polarize a field?
- Is neutrality possible in theoretical debates?
Another view
The statement assumes this polarization is a problem rather than a natural result of significant ideas.
More from Noam Chomsky
What he does in linguistics is exactly what he campaigns against in politics. He feeds off people. He doesn't allow anyone to disagree with him. --George Lakof…
Permalink to quote #289 Chomsky revived ideas that really had been kind of dormant since the Enlightenment of what is a human like and how does that tie in to our political arrangemen…
Permalink to quote #291 I don't pretend to think I'm as smart as Noam Chomsky, but I'm smart enough to ask him questions. --Bill Maher, February 27, 2007 [269]
Permalink to quote #288
Related quotes
Aliens invade the earth and threaten to obliterate it in a year's time unless human beings can find the Ramsey number for red five and blue five. We could mars…
Paul ErdosPaul Erdos quote #1 [The steady-state theory] was a minority view, but [Hoyle] and a few like-minded theorists were able to keep the plate spinning for years. Another Cambridge lu…
Martin RyleMartin Ryle quote #1 I firmly believe people have hitherto been a great deal too much taken up about doctrine and far too little about practice. The word doctrine, as used in the B…
George MacDonaldGeorge MacDonald quote #1