I would feel no hesitation in saying that it is the responsibility of a decent human being to give assistance to a child who is being attacked by a rabid dog, but I would not intend this to imply that in all imaginable circumstances one must, necessarily, act in accordance with this general responsibility. One can easily concoct imaginary situations in which it would be inadvisable, even immoral to do so [...] the assumption that it is reprehensible for a powerful nation to invade a weak and tiny neighbor in order to impose on it an 'acceptable' government [...] I did not, and will not defend, just as I would not take the trouble to justify my belief that one should assist a child being attacked by a rabid dog.
About this quote
- What does it mean?
- Helping a child attacked by a dog is a general responsibility, but not absolute; similarly, invading weak nations to impose government isn't justified.
- In plain terms
- Assisting victims is usually right, but it doesn't justify powerful nations invading weak ones.
- What can you take from it?
- Moral duties have limits; do not use them to justify invasion.
Where it applies
Putting it to work
Questions to consider
- When is intervention justified?
- Are moral rules absolute?
Another view
The analogy between dog attacks and war may be imperfect.
More from Noam Chomsky
I'm of course opposed to terror, any rational person is, but I think that if we're serious about the question of terror and serious about the question of viole…
Permalink to quote #65 Of course, everybody says they're for peace. Hitler was for peace. Everybody is for peace. The question is: what kind of peace?
Permalink to quote #67 In my view Columbia completely disgraced itself, as did the media and commentary generally... The morning of Ahmadenijad's speech at Columbia, the university w…
Permalink to quote #64
Related quotes
Our dreams of a pure virtue are dissolved in a situation in which it is possible to exercise the virtue of responsibility toward a community of nations only by…
Reinhold NiebuhrReinhold Niebuhr quote #23 Among so many conflicting ideas an so many different perspectives, the honest man is confused and distressed and the skeptic becomes wicked ... Since one must …
Napoleon BonaparteNapoleon Bonaparte quote #25 In a serious struggle there is no worse cruelty than to be magnanimous at an inopportune time.
Leon TrotskyLeon Trotsky quote #35