Reactions to our adversity are not entirely uniform. At the dovish extreme, we find Senator John Kerry, who warns that we should never again fight a war 'without committing enough resources to win'; no other flaw is mentioned. And there is President Carter, the noted moral teacher and human rights apostle, who assured us that we owe Vietnam no debt and have no responsibility to render it any assistance because 'the destruction was mutual,' an observation so uncontroversial as to pass with no reaction. [...] Properly statesmanlike, President Bush announces that 'It was a bitter conflict, but Hanoi knows today that we seek only answers without the threat of retribution for the past.' Their crimes against us can never be forgotten, but 'we can begin writing the last chapter of the Vietnam war' if they dedicate themselves with sufficient zeal to the MIAs. We might even 'begin helping the Vietnamese find and identify their own combatants missing in action,' [New York Times Asia correspondent] Crossette reports. The adjacent front-page story reports Japan's failure, once again, to 'unambiguously' accept the blame 'for its wartime aggression.'
About this quote
- What does it mean?
- The quote contrasts different political leaders' responses to the Vietnam war, highlighting varied moral and strategic stances.
- In plain terms
- Leaders had very different views on how to handle Vietnam.
- What can you take from it?
- Political narratives shape public perception of war outcomes.
Where it applies
Putting it to work
Questions to consider
- How do leaders' statements influence war policy?
- What role does moral framing play in public support?
Another view
The quote offers a selective view and may omit nuance.
More from Noam Chomsky
The Tet Offensive in January of 1968 [...] made the war unpopular. American corporate elites decided at that point that it just wasn't worth it, it was too cos…
Permalink to quote #80 The doves are pleased that [Robert McNamara] finally concedes that 'our blundering efforts to do good' turned into a 'dangerous mistake,' as Anthony Lewis put …
Permalink to quote #82 It goes back to the days when we were defending ourselves against the internal aggression of the Native American population, who we incidentally wiped out in t…
Permalink to quote #79
Related quotes
There is an imperialism that deserves all honor and respect - an imperialism of service in the discharge of great duties. But with too many it is the sense of …
Leonard H. CourtneyLeonard H. Courtney quote #1 Before 1938, the German generals were not opposed to Hitler because he produced the results they desired.
Werner von BlombergWerner von Blomberg quote #1 With humble duty, I wish to submit to you the following advice, acting in my capacity as your representative in Fiji. Owing to the uncertainty of the political…
Ratu Sir Penaia GanilauRatu Sir Penaia Ganilau quote #1