Does a son betray his father? If a father commands a son to commit a crime so terrible that the son can't do it and live with himself, then is it betrayal for the son to disobey his father?
About this quote
- What does it mean?
- Disobeying a father who orders a terrible crime may not be betrayal but moral resistance.
- In plain terms
- Refusing a horrific order from a father isn’t betrayal, it’s moral courage.
- What can you take from it?
- Moral duty can outweigh familial obedience.
Where it applies
Putting it to work
Questions to consider
- When does family loyalty become immoral?
- How can one navigate conflicting duties?
Another view
The scenario is extreme and may not reflect everyday moral choices.
More from Orson Scott Card
He would know what was right. Yet with his marvelous gift of knowing right from wrong, why couldn't he realize that his yearning to be something other than him…
Permalink to quote #463 You always do that. Make all the questions harder I make them truer
Permalink to quote #465 If you don't want to control what I think, why did you raise your voice? Why did you argue with me at all?
Permalink to quote #462
Related quotes
I will only make pictures that I won't be ashamed to have my children see.
Louis B. MayerLouis B. Mayer quote #1 That's why my girlfriend and I broke up: she wanted kids, and I : well, she wanted kids. [laughs] I had no idea her philosophy was that flawed. She goes, 'Woul…
Bill HicksBill Hicks quote #1 When in the summer of 1941 he (Hitler) gave me the order to prepare installations at Auschwitz where mass exterminations could take place, and personally to ca…
Rudolf HossRudolf Hoss quote #1