Skip to content
quotesby

Even if there's no such thing as free will, we have to treat each other as if there were free will in order to live together in society. Because otherwise, every time somebody does something terrible, you can't punish him, because he can't help it, because his genes or his environment or god made him do it, and every time somebody does something good, you can't honor him because he was a puppet, too. If you think that everybody around you is a puppet why bother talking to them at all? Why even try to plan anything or create anything, since everything you plan or create or desire or dream of is just acting out the script your puppeteer built into you.

Orson Scott Card#5

PhilosophySocietyAccountabilityFree willDeterminismPunishment

About this quote

What does it mean?
Society requires treating people as if they have free will, even if it doesn't exist, to allow for punishment and honor.
In plain terms
We act as if people choose their actions so we can hold them accountable.
What can you take from it?
Treat others as autonomous agents to maintain social order.

Where it applies

  • legal systems
  • interpersonal relationships
  • ethical debates

Putting it to work

  • justify punishment
  • honor achievements
  • plan collaborative projects

Questions to consider

  • Does pretending free will exists make it real?
  • How do you judge actions without intent?

Another view

If free will is an illusion, this framework is built on a false premise.

More from Orson Scott Card

  1. [It] was written and sold. I knew it was a strong story because I cared about it and believed in it. I had no idea that it would have the effect it had on the …

    Permalink to quote #4
  2. The priests say that God created our souls, and that just puts us under the control of another puppeteer. If God created our will, then he's responsible for ev…

    Permalink to quote #6
  3. The lies we live will always be confessed in the stories that we tell.

    Permalink to quote #3

Related quotes

  1. Free will is a golden thread running through the frozen matrix of fixed events.

    Robert A. HeinleinRobert A. Heinlein quote #23
  2. If the doctrine of free-will has raised up fanatics and persecutors, who, assuming that men may be good under all conditions if they merely wish to be so, have…

    Voltairine de CleyreVoltairine de Cleyre quote #40
  3. Destiny is an absolutely definite and inexorable ruler. Physical ability and moral determination count for nothing. It is impossible to perform the simplest ac…

    Aleister CrowleyAleister Crowley quote #64