Skip to content
quotesby

Movies make hash of the schoolmarm's approach of how well the artist fulfilled his intentions. Whatever the original intention of the writers and director, it is usually supplanted, as the production gets under way, by the intention to make money - and the industry judges the film by how well it fulfills that intention. But if you could see the 'artist's intentions' you'd probably wish you couldn't anyway. Nothing is so deathly to enjoyment as the relentless march of a movie to fulfill its obvious purpose. This is, indeed, almost a defining characteristic of the hack director, as distinguished from an artist.

Pauline Kael#13

ArtCriticismMoviesIndustryIntentionProfit

About this quote

What does it mean?
Kael argues that films are driven by profit, not artist intentions, and that intentions often become deathly to enjoyment.
In plain terms
Films prioritize profit over artist intentions which usually ruins the movie enjoyment.
What can you take from it?
Profit motives usually destroy the artistic value of a film.

Where it applies

  • film production
  • industry critique
  • art vs commerce

Putting it to work

  • analyze production goals
  • question studio motives
  • evaluate films

Questions to consider

  • Does profit always ruin art?
  • Can intentions survive production?

Another view

Sometimes clear artistic intentions help rather than hurt a film.

More from Pauline Kael

  1. Audiences who have been forced to wade through the thick middle-class padding of more expensively made movies to get to the action enjoy the nose-thumbing at '…

    Permalink to quote #12
  2. People who are just getting 'seriously interested' in film always ask a critic, 'Why don't you talk about technique and 'the visuals' more?' The answer is that…

    Permalink to quote #14
  3. Alienation is the most common state of the knowledgeable movie audience, and though it has the peculiar rewards of low connoisseurship, a miser's delight in sm…

    Permalink to quote #11

Related quotes

  1. The words 'Kiss Kiss Bang Bang,' which I saw on an Italian movie poster, are perhaps the briefest statement imaginable of the basic appeal of movies. This appe…

    Pauline KaelPauline Kael quote #8
  2. Movies are so rarely great art, that if we cannot appreciate great trash, we have very little reason to be interested in them.

    Pauline KaelPauline Kael quote #20
  3. Cancer research is a growth industry.

    George CarlinGeorge Carlin quote #127