It's sometimes discouraging to see all of a director's movies, because there's so much repetition. The auteurists took this to be a sign of a director's artistry, that you could recognize his movies. But it can also be a sign that he's a hack.
About this quote
- What does it mean?
- Seeing all of a director's films can reveal repetitive patterns that signal either artistic signature or a lack of creativity.
- In plain terms
- Repetition in a director's work can mean artistry or mediocrity.
- What can you take from it?
- Repetition alone does not prove artistic value.
Where it applies
Putting it to work
Questions to consider
- Is repetition always a flaw?
- How do you define artistry?
Another view
Some artists intentionally reuse motifs for specific effects.
More from Pauline Kael
Moviemaking is so male-dominated now that they think they're being pro-feminine when they have women punching each other out.
Permalink to quote #52 I still don't look at movies twice. It's funny, I just feel I got it the first time. With music it's different. People respond so differently to the whole issu…
Permalink to quote #54 Earlier generations went to see what was forbidden in life and developed a real excitement about the movies. Today's rating system keeps kids out of the good o…
Permalink to quote #51
Related quotes
And for the greatest movie artists where there is a unity of technique and subject, one doesn't need to talk about technique much because it has been subsumed …
Pauline KaelPauline Kael quote #17 The European boys have small ideas but they sure know how to dress 'em up.
George GershwinGeorge Gershwin quote #1 People call me an over-actor, people who say this might call Van Gogh an over- painter.
Jim CarreyJim Carrey quote #1