We live in an age which eschews sentimentality as if it were a good deal more than the devil. (Actually, of course, a writer may be just as sentimental in laying undue emphasis on sexual crimes as on dying mothers: sentimental, like scientific, is an adjective that relates to method, not to matter.)
About this quote
- What does it mean?
- The speaker argues that sentimentality depends on method rather than subject matter, criticizing how it is judged.
- In plain terms
- Sentimentality is about how you say things not what you say.
- What can you take from it?
- Evaluate emotion by method not topic.
Where it applies
Putting it to work
Questions to consider
- How do you judge emotional writing?
- Is sentimentality always bad?
Another view
The distinction between method and matter can be blurry in practice.
More from Randall Jarrell
You give me the feeling that the universe Was made by something more than human For something less than human. But I identify myself, as always, With something…
Permalink to quote #32 The writer does not get from his work as he writes and reads it the same aesthetic shock that the reader does; and since the writer is so accustomed to reading…
Permalink to quote #34 At night there are no more farmers, no more farms. At night the fields dream, the fields are the forest. The boy stands looking at the fox As if, if he looked …
Permalink to quote #31
Related quotes
One of the objections I have against Campbell's Astounding was that there was too little love in it. It was a very loveless magazine. They never took enough ac…
Brian AldissBrian Aldiss quote #7 It was a cold, disapproving gaze, such as a fastidious luncher who was not fond of caterpillars might have directed at one which he had discovered in his porti…
P. G. WodehouseP. G. Wodehouse quote #21 A splendid muse of fiction hath Charles Dickens, But now and then just as the interest thickens He stilts his pathos, and the reader sickens.
Charles DickensCharles Dickens quote #148