Skip to content
quotesby

His dogmatism is more wild and personal than we are accustomed to, completely unspoiled by the hedging 'equanimity' that weakens the style and temperament of so many of our serious writers. His murderous intuitive phrases are famous; but at the same time his mind is essentially conservative and takes as much joy in rescuing the reputation of a sleeping good writer as in chloroforming a mediocre one.

Randall Jarrell#54

WritingCriticismStyleDogmaIntegrityJustice

About this quote

What does it mean?
Some writers are harsh and dogmatic but also genuinely care about good work.
In plain terms
This writer is wild and critical but also loves to save good writers.
What can you take from it?
Even fierce critics can have deep respect for quality and talent.

Where it applies

  • literary review
  • critique
  • editorial work

Putting it to work

  • be fair in critique
  • support good work
  • balance harshness

Questions to consider

  • Can you be harsh and fair at once?
  • Does style matter more than intent?

Another view

Some critics use aggression to mask a lack of true respect.

More from Randall Jarrell

  1. I think that one possible definition of our modern culture is that it is one in which nine-tenths of our intellectuals can't read any poetry.

    Permalink to quote #53
  2. Your tenderness and terrorization, your prose sentences - like Bernini graves, staggeringly expensive, Italianate, warm, sentences once-and-for-all.

    Permalink to quote #55
  3. You often feel about something in Shakespeare or Dostoevsky that nobody ever said such a thing, but it's just the sort of thing people would say if they could …

    Permalink to quote #52

Related quotes

  1. Wilde was not a great poet nor a consummate prose writer. He was a very astute Irishman who encompassed in epigrams an esthetic credo which others before him s…

    Jorge Luis BorgesJorge Luis Borges quote #3
  2. As a man has no right to kill one of his children if it is diseased or insane, so a man who has made the gradual and conscious expression of his personality in…

    John Millington SyngeJohn Millington Synge quote #4
  3. Dr. Kettle was wont to say that Seneca writes as a Boare does pisse, scilicet by jirkes.

    John AubreyJohn Aubrey quote #7