Skip to content
quotesby

To have your poems criticized by Jarrell - when they didn't please him - was like meeting your fate, like a foretaste of death. To go with his daunting judgement, he had an unlimited stock of images for catching exactly each poet's inadequacies, so that their predicaments were far more vividly expressed than anything they themselves had written. Jarrell made literature out of their failure to make it.

Randall Jarrell#58

CriticismLiteratureFailureFearFeedback

About this quote

What does it mean?
Jarrell’s critiques are feared for their precision, often exposing failures more vividly than the work itself.
In plain terms
His criticism is so sharp it feels like death to the criticized.
What can you take from it?
Brutal honesty in critique can overshadow the original work.

Where it applies

  • literary criticism
  • peer review
  • education

Putting it to work

  • give specific feedback
  • prepare for critique

Questions to consider

  • Does harsh criticism help or hurt art?
  • How should writers handle failure?

Another view

Harsh critique may discourage creativity more than improve it.

More from Randall Jarrell

  1. Randall had a great flair for the poetry of desperation.

    Permalink to quote #57
  2. What he could do in poetry he did early and with prodigious security; he was one of our true poets for thirty years and practically the only American poet able…

    Permalink to quote #56
  3. Your tenderness and terrorization, your prose sentences - like Bernini graves, staggeringly expensive, Italianate, warm, sentences once-and-for-all.

    Permalink to quote #55

Related quotes

  1. If you are The Game, then quite frankly, you need to go back to the drawing board because your game absolutely sucks!

    Dwayne (The Rock) JohnsonDwayne (The Rock) Johnson quote #3
  2. Either criticism is no good at all (a very defensible position) or else criticism means saying about an author the very things that would have made him jump ou…

    Gilbert Keith ChestertonGilbert Keith Chesterton quote #26
  3. The poetical tendency of the present and of the preceding century has been divided in a manner singularly curious. One loud and conspicuous faction of bards, g…

    H. P. LovecraftH. P. Lovecraft quote #1