Everything that would be said against the Eixample's heirs, from Le Corbusier's 'ville radieuse' to Oscar Niemeyer's Brasilia, was already said, with far less justice, about the Eixample itself. And all its critics concurred that the basic mistake was to have left the planning of a city in the hands of a socialist.
About this quote
- What does it mean?
- Criticism aimed at later city planners was already applied unfairly to Eixample.
- In plain terms
- Critics said about later cities were already said unfairly about Eixample.
- What can you take from it?
- Urban plans are often judged too harshly.
Where it applies
Putting it to work
Questions to consider
- Are we too quick to critique cities?
- What makes planning fail?
Another view
Some urban plans do fail on core promises.
More from Robert Hughes
New Song rapidly accumulated a nucleus of talent, and its best-known group was Els Setze Jutges, The Sixteen Judges, whose odd-sounding name came from a phrase…
Permalink to quote #16 One thing is sure: the Sagrada Familia is the first Catholic temple whose bacon was ever saved by Shinto tourism. Not even Gaudi, who believed in miracles, cou…
Permalink to quote #18 Like most artists who have made an invention of some kind, he tends to overplay the significance of his own and goes on about it as though it were a Rosetta St…
Permalink to quote #15
Related quotes
There is no design involved. It would look tawdry down the wrong end of a beach in Torremolinos. This isn't a case of just not wanting it in my backyard. This …
David MellorDavid Mellor quote #2 Urbem neque pro maiestate imperii ornatam et inundationibus incendiisque obnoxiam excoluit adeo, ut iure sit gloriatus marmoream se relinquere, quam latericiam…
SuetoniusSuetonius quote #8 The Metropolis should have been aborted long before it became New York, London or Tokyo.
John Kenneth GalbraithJohn Kenneth Galbraith quote #33