Attending this new version, I felt oddly as if I were watching a provincial stock company doing the best it could without the Broadway cast. I was reminded of the child prodigy who was summoned to perform for a famous pianist. The child climbed onto the piano stool and played something by Chopin with great speed and accuracy. The great musician then patted the child on the head and said, 'You can play the notes. Someday, you may be able to play the music.'
About this quote
- What does it mean?
- Ebert uses an anecdote about a child prodigy to illustrate a performance that has technical skill but lacks emotional depth. The reviewer felt the production had precision but missed the essence of the work.
- In plain terms
- The show had technical accuracy but lacked the emotional depth of great art.
- What can you take from it?
- Technical proficiency does not guarantee artistic resonance or emotional impact.
Where it applies
Putting it to work
Questions to consider
- What separates playing notes from making music?
- Is technical skill enough for art?
Another view
Technical mastery can be valuable in its own right even without emotional depth.
More from Roger Ebert
It's like the high school production of something you saw at Steppenwolf, with the most gifted students in drama class playing the John Malkovich and Joan Alle…
Permalink to quote #48 Here's a movie that stretches out every moment for more than it's worth, until even the moments of inspiration seem forced. Since the basic idea of the movie i…
Permalink to quote #50 Pearl Harbor is a two-hour movie squeezed into three hours, about how on December 7, 1941, the Japanese staged a surprise attack on an American love triangle. …
Permalink to quote #47
Related quotes
People call me an over-actor, people who say this might call Van Gogh an over- painter.
Jim CarreyJim Carrey quote #1 Every good poet includes a critic; the reverse will not hold.
William ShenstoneWilliam Shenstone quote #4 The man who reacts to the universe with a cry of impotent anguish is acceptable as an artist only if he can persuade us that he has sanely considered the other…
Kenneth TynanKenneth Tynan quote #6