Highly intelligent and well-informed people disagree on every political issue. Therefore, intelligence and knowledge are useless for making decisions, because if any of that stuff helped, then all the smart people would have the same opinions. So use your 'gut instinct' to make voting choices. That is exactly like being clueless, but with the added advantage that you'll feel as if your random vote preserved democracy.
About this quote
- What does it mean?
- Smart, well-informed people disagree on politics, so intelligence doesn't guarantee consensus; thus, gut instinct is suggested for voting, which feels democratic but is essentially random.
- In plain terms
- Even experts disagree, so using intuition to vote feels democratic but is essentially random.
- What can you take from it?
- Recognize that expertise doesn’t resolve political disagreement, but random choices lack informed responsibility.
Where it applies
Putting it to work
Questions to consider
- How can citizens make better decisions without consensus among experts?
- What role should intuition play in voting?
Another view
Relying on gut instinct ignores the value of informed analysis and can undermine democratic quality.
More from Scott Adams
Every generation of humans believed it had all the answers it needed, except for a few mysteries they assumed would be solved at any moment. And they all belie…
Permalink to quote #32 So, I heard the Fed increased the money supply, but I checked my bank balance and it's the same as before.
Permalink to quote #31 People are so conditioned to take sides that a balanced analysis looks to them like hatred.
Permalink to quote #30
Related quotes
Democracy can't work. Mathematicians, peasants, and animals, that's all there is - so democracy, a theory based on the assumption that mathematicians and peasa…
Robert A. HeinleinRobert A. Heinlein quote #35 Decision by majorities is as much an expedient as lighting by gas.
William Ewart GladstoneWilliam Ewart Gladstone quote #2 But the mass of the old electors did not analyse very much: they liked to have one of their 'betters' to represent them; if he was rich they respected him much…
Walter BagehotWalter Bagehot quote #2