Skip to content
quotesby

[W]hat intellectual phenomenon can be older, or more oft repeated, than the story of a large research program that impaled itself upon a false central assumption accepted by all practitioners? Do we regard all people who worked within such traditions as dishonorable fools? What of the scientists who assumed that the continents were stable, that the hereditary material was protein, or that all other galaxies lay within the Milky Way? These false and abandoned efforts were pursued with passion by brilliant and honorable scientists. How many current efforts, now commanding millions of research dollars and the full attention of many of our best scientists, will later be exposed as full failures based on false premises?

Stephen Jay Gould#107

ScienceHistoryTruthResearchHumilityAssumptions

About this quote

What does it mean?
Many great scientists have pursued false central assumptions with passion and honor, suggesting current popular research might also be based on flawed premises.
In plain terms
Brilliant people can work hard on wrong ideas, so we should be humble about today's accepted theories.
What can you take from it?
Scientific passion does not guarantee truth.

Where it applies

  • reviewing research programs
  • questioning consensus
  • evaluating scientific claims

Putting it to work

  • challenge central assumptions
  • review research biases
  • encourage skepticism

Questions to consider

  • Which current scientific beliefs might be wrong?
  • How do we distinguish passion from error?

Another view

Progress often depends on accepting some assumptions temporarily until disproven.

More from Stephen Jay Gould

  1. Great theories are expansive; failures mire us in dogmatism and tunnel vision.

    Permalink to quote #106
  2. [S]cience is often regarded as the most objective and truth-directed of human enterprises, and since direct observation is supposed to be the favored route to …

    Permalink to quote #108
  3. Good scholars struggle to understand the world in an integral way (pedants bite off tiny bits and worry them to death). These visions of reality [:] demand our…

    Permalink to quote #105

Related quotes

  1. I am acutely aware of the fact that the marriage between mathematics and physics, which was so enormously fruitful in past centuries, has recently ended in div…

    Freeman DysonFreeman Dyson quote #1
  2. If I have not seen as far as others, it is because giants were standing on my shoulders.

    Hal AbelsonHal Abelson quote #1
  3. It is the man of science, eager to have his every opinion regenerated, his every idea rationalized, by drinking at the fountain of fact, and devoting all the e…

    Charles Sanders PeirceCharles Sanders Peirce quote #2