Skip to content
quotesby

Darwin grasped the philosophical bleakness with his characteristic courage. He argued that hope and morality cannot, and should not, be passively read in the construction of nature. Aesthetic and moral truths, as human concepts, must be shaped in human terms, not 'discovered' in nature. We must formulate these answers for ourselves and then approach nature as a partner who can answer other kinds of questions for us-questions about the factual state of the universe, not about the meaning of human life. If we grant nature the independence of her own domain-her answers unframed in human terms-then we can grasp her exquisite beauty in a free and humble way. For then we become liberated to approach nature without the burden of an inappropriate and impossible quest for moral messages to assuage our hopes and fears. We can pay our proper respect to nature's independence and read her own ways as beauty or inspiration in our different terms.

Stephen Jay Gould#159

ScienceNaturePhilosophyMoralityMeaning

About this quote

What does it mean?
Gould argues that morality and hope are human constructs, not truths found in nature. We should treat nature as a partner for factual questions, not as a source of moral guidance.
In plain terms
Humans create meaning and morals; nature only provides facts.
What can you take from it?
Separate human meaning from natural facts to respect both.

Where it applies

  • reading science texts
  • philosophical debate
  • environmental ethics

Putting it to work

  • study nature for data not morals
  • define your own ethical framework

Questions to consider

  • Can nature have value without human meaning?
  • Where should we look for moral truths?

Another view

This view might discourage finding intrinsic value in the natural world.

More from Stephen Jay Gould

  1. No more harmful nonsense exists than [the] common supposition that deepest insight into great questions about the meaning of life or the structure of reality e…

    Permalink to quote #158
  2. Complex organisms cannot be construed as the sum of their genes, nor do genes alone build particular items of anatomy or behavior by themselves. Most genes inf…

    Permalink to quote #160
  3. In return for this great gift that I could not repay in a thousand lifetimes, at least I can promise that, although I have frequently advanced wrong, or even s…

    Permalink to quote #157

Related quotes

  1. We should therefore, with grace and optimism, embrace NOMA's tough-minded demand: Acknowledge the personal character of these human struggles about morals and …

    Stephen Jay GouldStephen Jay Gould quote #1
  2. Our failure to discern a universal good does not record any lack of insight or ingenuity, but merely demonstrates that nature contains no moral messages framed…

    Stephen Jay GouldStephen Jay Gould quote #28
  3. The criterion which we use to test the genuineness of apparent statements of fact is the criterion of verifiability. We say that a sentence is factually signif…

    Alfred AyerAlfred Ayer quote #1