Skip to content
quotesby

Debate is an art form. It is about the winning of arguments. It is not about the discovery of truth. There are certain rules and procedures to debate that really have nothing to do with establishing fact-which creationists have mastered. Some of those rules are: never say anything positive about your own position because it can be attacked, but chip away at what appear to be the weaknesses in your opponent's position. They are good at that. I don't think I could beat the creationists at debate. I can tie them. But in courtrooms they are terrible, because in courtrooms you cannot give speeches. In a courtroom you have to answer direct questions about the positive status of your belief. We destroyed them in Arkansas. On the second day of the two-week trial we had our victory party!

Stephen Jay Gould#4

ScienceTruthDebate

About this quote

What does it mean?
Debate favors argument tactics over truth; courtrooms demand direct answers, where scientists can expose falsehoods that debaters can hide.
In plain terms
Debate rules let liars avoid facts by attacking opponents. In court, you must answer yes or no, which reveals the truth.
What can you take from it?
Recognize that debate formats often obscure truth, while direct questioning exposes it.

Where it applies

  • scientific advocacy
  • media engagement
  • legal trials

Putting it to work

  • preparing for court testimony
  • choosing communication formats

Questions to consider

  • Does modern media reward truth or performance?
  • How can scientists communicate effectively without being tricked?

Another view

Not all public discourse benefits from courtroom-style pressure; some nuance gets lost.

More from Stephen Jay Gould

  1. But, as we consider the totality of similarly broad and fundamental aspects of life, we cannot defend division by two as a natural principle of objective order…

    Permalink to quote #3
  2. I am not unmindful of the journalist's quip that yesterday's paper wraps today's garbage. I am also not unmindful of the outrages visited upon our forests to p…

    Permalink to quote #5
  3. I want to argue that the 'sudden' appearance of species in the fossil record and our failure to note subsequent evolutionary change within them is the proper p…

    Permalink to quote #6

Related quotes

  1. Does there truly exist an insuperable contradiction between religion and science? Can religion be superseded by science? The answers to these questions have, f…

    Albert EinsteinAlbert Einstein quote #130
  2. [T]his theme of mutually invisible life at widely differing scales bears an important implication for the 'culture wars' that supposedly now envelop our univer…

    Stephen Jay GouldStephen Jay Gould quote #156
  3. The criterion which we use to test the genuineness of apparent statements of fact is the criterion of verifiability. We say that a sentence is factually signif…

    Alfred AyerAlfred Ayer quote #1