When we seek a textbook case for the proper operation of science, the correction of certain error offers far more promise than the establishment of probable truth. Confirmed hunches, of course, are more upbeat than discredited hypotheses. Since the worst traditions of 'popular' writing falsely equate instruction with sweetness and light, our promotional literature abounds with insipid tales in the heroic mode, although tough stories of disappointment and loss give deeper insight into a methodology that the celebrated philosopher Karl Popper once labeled as 'conjecture and refutation.'
About this quote
- What does it mean?
- Science advances more through correcting errors than confirming truths, yet popular writing often ignores this reality. Real scientific insight comes from disappointment and refutation, not just heroic success stories.
- In plain terms
- Science learns more from fixing mistakes than proving things right, but stories often hide this truth.
- What can you take from it?
- Understand that scientific progress relies on refutation and error correction.
Where it applies
Putting it to work
Questions to consider
- How do you react to failed hypotheses?
- What stories about science do you find misleading?
Another view
Overemphasizing error might discourage scientists from making bold claims.
More from Stephen Jay Gould
Science is a method for testing claims about the natural world, not an immutable compendium of absolute truths. The fundamentalists, by 'knowing' the answers b…
Permalink to quote #91 The story of a theory's failure often strikes readers as sad and unsatisfying. Since science thrives on self-correction, we who practice this most challenging …
Permalink to quote #93 Guessing right for the wrong reason does not merit scientific immortality.
Permalink to quote #90
Related quotes
Yet scientists are required to back up their claims not with private feelings but with publicly checkable evidence. Their experiments must have rigorous contro…
Richard DawkinsRichard Dawkins quote #112 Learn, compare, collect the facts!
Ivan PavlovIvan Pavlov quote #4 But man has still another powerful resource: natural science with its strictly objective methods.
Ivan PavlovIvan Pavlov quote #10