In the early days of his government, Tony Blair liked to paraphrase the famous joke from Monty Python's Life of Brian ('All right, but apart from sanitation, medicine, education, wine, public order, irrigation, roads, the fresh-water system and public health, what have the Romans ever done for us?') in order ironically to disarm his critics: 'They betrayed socialism. True, they brought more social security, they did a lot for healthcare and education, and so on, but, in spite of all that, they betrayed socialism.' As it is clear today, it is, rather, the reverse which applies: 'We remain socialists. True, we practice Thatcherism in economics, we attack asylum-seekers, beggars and single mothers, we made a deal with Murdoch, and so on, but, none the less, we're still socialists.'
About this quote
- What does it mean?
- Blair ironically uses a Monty Python joke to argue that despite economic reforms and harsh policies, his party remains socialist in identity.
- In plain terms
- He jokes that his party kept socialism even while adopting conservative economic tactics.
- What can you take from it?
- Political identity often persists despite policy shifts.
Where it applies
Putting it to work
Questions to consider
- Can a party be socialist while practicing conservative economics?
- How does irony serve political defense?
Another view
The joke may obscure genuine policy failures rather than illuminate them.
More from Tony Blair
Tony Blair, a passionate Christian, has expressed his conviction that WMDs will be found in almost directly religious terms of credo quia absurdum: despite the…
Permalink to quote #74 Yo Blair, how are you doin'?
Permalink to quote #76 Like millions of others, I now bitterly resent that a prime minister could use such a farrago of lies and manipulation to deceive us and to take the nation to …
Permalink to quote #73
Related quotes
We must take from the right nationalism without capitalism and from the left socialism without internationalism.
Gregor StrasserGregor Strasser quote #1 Almost the only persons who may be said to comprehend even approximately the significance, principles, and purposes of Socialism are the chief leaders of the e…
Benjamin TuckerBenjamin Tucker quote #1 The Communists, following Hegel, speak of humanity and its future as of some monolithic individuality. I was attacking this illusion.
Simone De BeauvoirSimone De Beauvoir quote #2