Skip to content
quotesby

What could be more absurd, to begin with, than our attitude of high moral outrage against other nations for manufacturing the selfsame weapons that we manufacture? The difference, as our leaders say, is that we will use these weapons virtuously, whereas our enemies will use them maliciously-a proposition that too readily conforms to a proposition of much less dignity: we will use them in our interest, whereas our enemies will use them in theirs.

Wendell Berry#43

Foreign policyHypocrisyInterestsMoralityWeapons

About this quote

What does it mean?
It is absurd to condemn other nations for making weapons we also make. The claimed moral difference is really just about whose interests are served.
In plain terms
We act angry at other countries for making weapons we make too because it benefits them.
What can you take from it?
Moral outrage over weapons often masks self-interest.

Where it applies

  • analyzing foreign policy
  • discussing arms trade
  • evaluating moral claims

Putting it to work

  • question moral claims
  • identify self-interest
  • compare policies equally

Questions to consider

  • Does intent justify owning weapons?
  • How do we judge other nations fairly?

Another view

Some argue intentions matter more than the weapons themselves.

More from Wendell Berry

  1. Violence breeds violence. Acts of violence committed in 'justice' or in affirmation of 'rights' or in defense of 'peace' do not end violence. They prepare and …

    Permalink to quote #42
  2. I think we must be careful about too easily accepting, or being too easily grateful for, sacrifices made by others, especially if we have made none ourselves.

    Permalink to quote #44
  3. We cling in our public life to a brutal hypocrisy. In our century of almost universal violence of humans against fellow humans, and against our natural and cul…

    Permalink to quote #41

Related quotes

  1. On what moral grounds can the rulers of a nation in which millionaires and beggars exist; Indians are exterminated; Blacks are discriminated against; women are…

    Fidel CastroFidel Castro quote #12
  2. It's certainly true that the world is better off without Saddam Hussein, and also without the people who supported him through his worst atrocities, and are no…

    Noam ChomskyNoam Chomsky quote #114
  3. The good thing about being a hypocrite is that you get to keep your values.

    Alan AldaAlan Alda quote #1