Skip to content
quotesby

It is a fallacy to think that carping is the strongest form of criticism: the important work begins after the artist's mistakes have been pointed out, and the reviewer can't put it off indefinitely with sneers, although some neophytes might be tempted to try: 'When in doubt, stick out your tongue' is a safe rule that never cost one any readers. But there's nothing strong about it, and it has nothing to do with the real business of criticism, which is to do justice to the best work of one's time, so that nothing gets lost.

Wilfrid Sheed#40

ArtWritingCriticismJournalismReview

About this quote

What does it mean?
Criticism isn't just about pointing out mistakes; the real work is preserving and doing justice to the best art of the era.
In plain terms
True criticism builds up great work, not just tears it down.
What can you take from it?
Focus on honoring the best art rather than just mocking errors.

Where it applies

  • book reviews
  • art critique
  • media commentary

Putting it to work

  • write constructive reviews
  • highlight quality work
  • avoid pure negativity

Questions to consider

  • What makes criticism constructive?
  • How do we preserve great art?

Another view

Some critics may prefer controversy over genuine appreciation.

More from Wilfrid Sheed

  1. Not that there weren't real communists in the labor unions, and real spies in Washington, but these had nothing to do with the show that was being put on for u…

    Permalink to quote #39
  2. Off she'd go to the hospital, a place I believe she secretly liked because they treat you like a child there.

    Permalink to quote #41
  3. Saloons provide moments of genuine ecstasy - but only if your soul is at peace and the rest of your life bears contemplating. Otherwise, they are palaces of mi…

    Permalink to quote #38

Related quotes

  1. The best of our fiction is by novelists who allow that it is as good as they can give, and the worst by novelists who maintain that they could do much better i…

    J. M. BarrieJ. M. Barrie quote #1
  2. I regard criticism as an art, and if in this country and in this age it is practiced with honesty, it is no more remunerative than the work of an avant-garde f…

    Pauline KaelPauline Kael quote #1
  3. I see journalists as the manual workers, the laborers of the word. Journalism can only be literature when it is passionate.

    Marguerite DurasMarguerite Duras quote #3