Mostel: If I appeared there, what if I did an imitation of a butterfly at rest? There is no crime in making anybody laugh. I don't care if you laugh at me. Congressman Jackson: If your interpretation of a butterfly at rest brought any money into the coffers of the Communist Party, you contributed directly to the propaganda effort of the Communist Party. Mostel: Suppose I had the urge to do the butterfly at rest somewhere? Congressman Doyle: Yes, but please, when you have the urge, don't have such an urge to put the butterfly at rest by putting some money in the Communist Party coffers as a result of that urge to put a butterfly at rest.
About this quote
- What does it mean?
- Mostel argues that comedy and imitation are innocent acts, while officials interpret any financial benefit to communists as propaganda.
- In plain terms
- Laughing is not a crime, but officials accuse artists of funding enemies if their work indirectly helps them.
- What can you take from it?
- Artists face scrutiny when their humor or art intersects with political sensitivities.
Where it applies
Putting it to work
Questions to consider
- Can humor ever be truly neutral in a political climate?
- How do artists defend their intent against interpretation?
Another view
The dialogue shows how satire can be twisted into evidence of guilt.
More from Zero Mostel
There's a kind of silliness in the theater about what one contributes to a show. The producer obviously contributes the money... but must the actor contribute …
Permalink to quote #1 You should have told him (Jewison) to get Topol's son!
Permalink to quote #3 With kikes like you on the loose, who needs Hitler?
Permalink to quote #4
Related quotes
We had a dim premonition that power-mad gangsters would one day use art itself as a way of deadening men's minds.
Hans ArpHans Arp quote #1 As long as I am mayor of this city the great industries are secure. We hear about constitutional rights, free speech and the free press. Every time I hear thes…
Frank HagueFrank Hague quote #2 In Russia we only had two TV channels. Channel One was propaganda. Channel Two consisted of a KGB officer telling you: Turn back at once to Channel One.
Yakov SmirnoffYakov Smirnoff quote #4