Be Curious, Not Judgmental: Not Whitman, Here’s the Story
A pub, a dartboard and a smug opponent. In the eighth episode of the first season of Ted Lasso, “The Diamond Dogs”, first shown on 18 September 2020, Ted takes on his rival Rupert in a game of darts for a bet, wins, and along the way credits a line to Walt Whitman: “Be curious, not judgmental.”
The scene made the phrase famous, and the credit went with it. But Whitman never wrote it. The earliest known printing is in an American newspaper advice column from 1986. This article follows the line backwards from the television to its real origin, then shows what Whitman did write about curiosity, so you can quote him properly.
2020: how a TV coach made it go viral
The line fits the show perfectly. Ted is a man other characters keep misjudging, and the darts game turns that into his advantage. Since the episode, the phrase has turned up on posters, mugs and office slides, very often with Whitman’s name underneath.
That is the problem. A television character is allowed to misremember a quotation. The audience then copies the misremembering and prints it as fact.
1986: the earliest known printing
According to fact-checking work by Snopes, reported by the Charlotte Observer in a May 2023 article on the line’s origin, the first known appearance is in the Charlotte Observer of 16 January 1986. It was part of a syndicated advice column by Marguerite and Marshall Shearer, distributed nationally by Knight-Ridder.
The context is a long way from darts. A parent had written in after finding oral contraceptives in their 17-year-old daughter’s bedroom. The phrase appeared in the columnists’ reply, and that is the earliest dated use anyone has found. It may not be the first; advice columns often repeat phrases already common in counselling. But it is decades after Whitman’s death in 1892.
What the Whitman experts say
Ed Folsom, a professor of English at the University of Iowa and co-director of the Walt Whitman Archive, told Snopes that Whitman never said or wrote the phrase. Few people know the poet’s texts better.
Wikiquote’s Walt Whitman page files the line under “Disputed”, noting that it has no source and that the closest phrase in Leaves of Grass is “Be not curious about God”. As you will see below, that closest phrase says almost the opposite.
Three dates to remember
| Year | What happened |
|---|---|
| 1855 | First edition of Leaves of Grass; no such line in it or in any later edition |
| 1986 | Earliest known printing, in a syndicated advice column |
| 2020 | Ted Lasso credits it to Whitman, and the misattribution spreads |
What Whitman actually wrote about curiosity
Whitman was a deeply curious poet, which is partly why the misattribution feels right. Here are his real lines, all from Leaves of Grass, which you can read in full in Project Gutenberg’s free edition.
The watcher, from “Song of Myself”, section 4
“Looking with side-curved head curious what will come next,
Both in and out of the game and watching and wondering at it.”
This is the nearest thing in Whitman to the Ted Lasso idea: a self that stands a little apart, watching and wondering rather than ruling on what it sees. If you want a genuine Whitman line for a talk about curiosity, this is it.
The line that sounds like the opposite, from section 48
“And I say to mankind, Be not curious about God,
For I who am curious about each am not curious about God.”
Whitman is not telling readers to stop asking questions. The next lines explain: “I hear and behold God in every object”, and “In the faces of men and women I see God”. He finds God in every ordinary thing and person, so he has no need to speculate about God in the abstract. Quoting only “Be not curious” would turn it into the reverse of what he meant.
The questioner, from “Crossing Brooklyn Ferry”
“I too felt the curious abrupt questionings stir within me.”
Later in the same poem comes the command “Throb, baffled and curious brain! throw out questions and answers!” Both lines are about curiosity as something felt, almost physical, which is a long way from a slogan.
How to use the phrase without the false credit
The advice itself is good, and you do not need Whitman’s name to use it. Some honest options:
- Credit the show: “As Ted Lasso put it, be curious, not judgmental.” Accurate, and everyone knows the scene.
- Credit the saying: “There’s an old piece of advice, often wrongly credited to Walt Whitman: be curious, not judgmental.”
- Swap in real Whitman: “Both in and out of the game and watching and wondering at it.”
The phrase is popular with parents and teachers, because it describes how to respond when a child says something surprising: ask before you rule. If that is your setting, this guide to the Socratic method at home turns the idea into a practical way of talking with children.
For more of the poet’s verified lines, see our Walt Whitman page, and for other sourced lines on the subject, browse quotes about curiosity.
Frequently Asked Questions
Did Walt Whitman say “be curious, not judgmental”?
No. The line does not appear anywhere in Whitman’s published work, and Ed Folsom, co-director of the Walt Whitman Archive, told Snopes that Whitman never said or wrote it. The earliest known printing is a 1986 syndicated advice column, almost a century after Whitman died in 1892.
Which Ted Lasso episode has the darts scene?
It is season 1, episode 8, “The Diamond Dogs”, first shown on 18 September 2020. Ted wins a bet against Rupert in a game of darts at the pub and attributes “be curious, not judgmental” to Walt Whitman during the game. The scene is the main reason the misattribution spread so widely.
Is there a real Walt Whitman quote about curiosity?
Yes. In “Song of Myself” he describes himself “Looking with side-curved head curious what will come next, / Both in and out of the game and watching and wondering at it.” In “Crossing Brooklyn Ferry” he writes “I too felt the curious abrupt questionings stir within me.” Both are in Leaves of Grass.