Quotes Misattributed to Einstein, and Where They Came From
Quick test before you read on. Which of these did Albert Einstein actually say?
- “Insanity is doing the same thing over and over and expecting different results.”
- “Everybody is a genius. But if you judge a fish by its ability to climb a tree, it will live its whole life believing that it is stupid.”
- “Two things are infinite: the universe and human stupidity; and I’m not sure about the universe.”
- “Compound interest is the most powerful force in the universe.”
- “Imagination is more important than knowledge.”
Only the last one has a documented source: a 1929 magazine interview. The first four are among the most shared Einstein “quotes” online, and none can be traced to anything he wrote or was reliably recorded saying. Here is where each one really came from, the reference book to check before you post an Einstein line, and some genuine alternatives that say much the same thing.
“Insanity is doing the same thing over and over”: a recovery-group line from 1981
This is probably the most popular Einstein misattribution of all. It is also pinned on Benjamin Franklin and Mark Twain. Wikiquote’s Albert Einstein page gives the earliest known version, from the November 1981 approval draft of the Narcotics Anonymous “Basic Text”:
“Insanity is repeating the same mistakes and expecting different results.”
Two years later, the novelist Rita Mae Brown used a version in her 1983 book Sudden Death (page 68), which is why she is often named as the source. Wikiquote’s view is that she was paraphrasing a saying already in circulation.
The recovery-group origin makes sense of the line. In context it describes the cycle of addiction: repeating a behaviour that has never worked while hoping this time will be different. Attached to Einstein, it becomes a vague remark about scientific method, which is not what it was for.
Use instead: credit it as “a saying from Narcotics Anonymous literature, 1981”, which is both accurate and more interesting.
The fish that cannot climb a tree: a 2004 self-help book
The research site Quote Investigator traced this one in its history of the fish-and-tree saying. The earliest close match it found is from 2004, in Matthew Kelly’s self-help book The Rhythm of Life, in a chapter titled “Everybody Is a Genius”. That is almost fifty years after Einstein died in 1955.
The idea behind it is much older. An 1898 “educational allegory” by the physicist Amos Dolbear, published under the pen name “Aesop, Jr.”, described an animal school in which every creature was made to study every subject regardless of what it was built for. Versions of that fable were reprinted for decades.
Quote Investigator also notes that the line is absent from The Ultimate Quotable Einstein, the Princeton University Press collection edited by Alice Calaprice. That book, which gives a source for each genuine quotation, is the standard check.
“Two things are infinite”: a secondhand memory
This one at least has a witness. The psychotherapist Fritz Perls wrote in his 1969 book Gestalt Therapy Verbatim: “As Albert Einstein once said to me: ‘Two things are infinite: the universe and human stupidity.'” That is the earliest published attribution Wikiquote records.
So it is not impossible that Einstein said something like it in conversation. But the only evidence is Perls’s recollection, published decades later. The famous punchline, “and I’m not sure about the former”, is a later addition. The earliest version Wikiquote found is from 1988.
Use instead: if you quote it, say “according to Fritz Perls”. If your real point is that people overrate their own knowledge, the documented psychology is more useful than the joke: this explainer on the Dunning-Kruger effect when learning a new skill covers what the research found and what it does not show.
Compound interest: a finance-blog favourite
Variants say compound interest is “the most powerful force in the universe”, “man’s greatest invention” or “the eighth wonder of the world”. Wikiquote summarises the research: Snopes rated its status uncertain, and Quote Investigator concluded it is most likely a false attribution, since variants date back at least to 1916 and the early ones are not credited to Einstein.
Four more lines that are not his
| Line | Where it actually comes from |
|---|---|
| “Time is nature’s way of keeping everything from happening at once.” | Ray Cummings’s 1921 story “The Time Professor”; later quoted by the physicist John Wheeler |
| “Not everything that can be counted counts…” | Sociologist William Bruce Cameron, 1963 |
| “Coincidence is God’s way of remaining anonymous.” | Probably a translation of a line attributed to Albert Schweitzer |
| “Everything is energy… This is not philosophy. This is physics.” | No evidence Einstein said it, per Quote Investigator |
Why Einstein attracts so many fakes
His name works as a stamp of intelligence. Put “Einstein” under a sentence and it reads as clever, whatever it says. He also spoke in public often and gave many interviews, so a new “quote” sounds plausible. And because he wrote in German, a reader who cannot find an English source may assume it is a translation from somewhere obscure.
The general pattern, where an anonymous line drifts toward the most famous plausible name, is covered in our explainer on how famous quotes get misattributed.
Four red flags in an “Einstein” quote
- It flatters the reader. “Everybody is a genius” is the kind of thing posters say, not physicists.
- It sounds like modern self-help. Words such as “frequency”, “manifest” or “the universe” used as a person are a strong signal.
- No date, no source. Real lines come with a letter, book, interview or speech.
- It is missing from Calaprice. If The Ultimate Quotable Einstein does not give it a source, treat it as doubtful.
Genuine Einstein lines you can use instead
These have sources you can cite:
- “Imagination is more important than knowledge. Knowledge is limited. Imagination encircles the world.” From an interview with George Sylvester Viereck, “What Life Means to Einstein”, The Saturday Evening Post, 26 October 1929.
- “The important thing is not to stop questioning. Curiosity has its own reason for existence.” From a statement to William Miller printed in LIFE magazine, 2 May 1955.
Both are explored further in our piece on Einstein, imagination and curiosity. For a wider view of what working scientists actually said, see our collection of sourced science quotes.
Frequently Asked Questions
Did Einstein say the definition of insanity?
No. There is no record of him saying it. The earliest known version is in the 1981 approval draft of the Narcotics Anonymous Basic Text: “Insanity is repeating the same mistakes and expecting different results.” Rita Mae Brown used a version in her 1983 novel Sudden Death. The Einstein credit came later.
Who said “if you judge a fish by its ability to climb a tree”?
No original author is known. The earliest close version found by Quote Investigator is in Matthew Kelly’s 2004 book The Rhythm of Life, which credits Einstein without a source. The idea echoes an 1898 animal-school allegory by Amos Dolbear. It does not appear in Alice Calaprice’s authoritative Einstein collection.
Is “two things are infinite” a real Einstein quote?
It rests on a single secondhand report. Fritz Perls wrote in 1969 that Einstein once said it to him. No letter, article or recording confirms it, and the “not sure about the universe” ending appears much later. If you use it, credit it as Einstein according to Perls.
What is the best book for checking Einstein quotes?
The Ultimate Quotable Einstein, edited by Alice Calaprice and published by Princeton University Press, gives a documented source for each genuine quotation, so a line that is missing from it deserves suspicion. Wikiquote’s Einstein page, which cites sources for each entry, is a convenient free starting point.
Did Einstein say compound interest is the eighth wonder of the world?
There is no good evidence that he did. Quote Investigator found variants of the compound interest saying from at least 1916, without any credit to Einstein, and judged the attribution most likely false. Snopes rated it uncertain. It is best treated as an anonymous finance saying.