Skip to content
quotesby

I write to say that in the idea of the three American states' ultimate independence, whether separately or in union, I see nothing fanciful. [Such] are at present the dominating trends in the U.S. that I see no other means of ultimate preservation of cultural and societal values that will not only be endangered but eventually destroyed by an endlessly prolonged association : with the remainder of what is now the U.S.A.

George F. Kennan#16

PoliticsCultureIndependencePreservation

About this quote

What does it mean?
The author argues that independence for certain states is necessary to preserve cultural values threatened by prolonged US association.
In plain terms
Independence for some states preserves culture that long US association destroys.
What can you take from it?
Political separation may be needed to protect unique cultural values.

Where it applies

  • political movement
  • secession debate
  • cultural preservation

Putting it to work

  • Protect local culture
  • Consider regional autonomy

Questions to consider

  • When does unity harm culture?
  • Is separation always better?

Another view

Unity often brings economic or security benefits worth the cost.

More from George F. Kennan

  1. Reading, in contrast to sitting before the screen, is not a purely passive exercise. The child, particularly one who reads a book dealing with real life, has n…

    Permalink to quote #15
  2. We are, if territory and population be looked at together, one of the great countries of the world - a monster country, one might say, along with others such a…

    Permalink to quote #17
  3. There will be no room, here, for the smug myopia which views American civilization as the final solution to all world problems; which recommends our institutio…

    Permalink to quote #14

Related quotes

  1. The fabulous Eva, Government Glad-Hand Girl No. 1 of the extravagant political novelette that is Argentina.

    James CameronJames Cameron quote #1
  2. The hippies, who had never really believed they were the wave of the future anyway, saw the election results as brutal confirmation of the futility of fighting…

    Hunter S. ThompsonHunter S. Thompson quote #1
  3. If we can't stamp out literature in the country, we can at least stop its being brought in from outside.

    Evelyn WaughEvelyn Waugh quote #1