They [the wise spirits of antiquity in the first circle of Dante's Inferno] are condemned, Dante tells us, to no other penalty than to live in desire without hope, a fate appropriate to noble souls with a clear vision of life.
About this quote
- What does it mean?
- Noble souls with clear vision may still face unfulfilled desires if they lack hope, as seen in Dante's depiction of virtuous pagans.
- In plain terms
- Even noble people suffer if they can see what they want but have no hope of getting it.
- What can you take from it?
- Hope is essential for a fulfilling life alongside vision.
Where it applies
Putting it to work
Questions to consider
- Can you have a clear vision without hope?
- What gives your desires hope?
Another view
This interprets Dante's theology rather than offering a universal psychological truth.
More from George Santayana
There is nothing impossible in the existence of the supernatural: its existence seems to me decidedly probable.
Permalink to quote #5 I leave you but the sound of many a word In mocking echoes haply overheard, I sang to heaven. My exile made me free, from world to world, from all worlds carri…
Permalink to quote #7 All his life he [the American] jumps into the train after it has started and jumps out before it has stopped; and he never once gets left behind, or breaks a l…
Permalink to quote #4
Related quotes
Why , alas! is life decreed Full of pain and full of sorrow? All uncertain as it is, Can we rest upon to-morrow? Why should blessings yet in store, Hold us sti…
Elizabeth BathElizabeth Bath quote #2 Le malheur est que, parfois, des souhaits s'accomplissent, afin que se perpetue le supplice de l'esperance.
Marguerite YourcenarMarguerite Yourcenar quote #2 It may be we shall know in the hereafter Why we, begetting hopes, give birth to fears, And why the world's too beautiful for laughter, Too gross for tears.
Percy AddleshawPercy Addleshaw quote #3