Such... was the theory (an outgrowth of Malthusian) of the selection and struggle for existence as the basis of human progress. Such again, is Marx's theory, with regard to the gradual destruction of small private production by large capitalistic production... as an inevitable decree of fate. However unfounded such theories are, however contrary to all that is known and confessed by humanity, and however obviously immoral these may be, they are accepted with credulity, pass uncriticized, and are preached... To this class belongs this astonishing theory of the Baungarten trinity - Goodness, Beauty and Truth - according to which it appears that the very best that can be done by the art of nations after 1900 years of Christian teaching is to choose as the ideal of their life that which was held by a small, semi-savage, slaveholding people who lived 2000 years ago, who imitated the nude human body extremely well, and erected buildings pleasing to the eye. Educated people write long, nebulous treatises on beauty as a member of the aesthetic trinity of beauty, truth, and goodness... and they all think that by pronouncing these sacrosanct words, they speak of something quite definite and solid... on which they can base their opinions. ...only for the purpose of justifying the false importance we attribute to an art that conveys every feeling, provided those feelings give us pleasure.
About this quote
- What does it mean?
- Tolstoy criticizes theories like Malthusianism and Marxism as unfounded and immoral, comparing the Baumgarten trinity to adopting ideals from a slaveholding people.
- In plain terms
- Tolstoy says theories like Malthus and Marx are immoral and unfounded, just as the Baumgarten trinity adopts ideals from ancient slaveholders.
- What can you take from it?
- Unfounded theories can be accepted as moral even if they ignore human values.
Where it applies
Putting it to work
Questions to consider
- Can theories be morally wrong?
- How do we judge historical ideals?
Another view
Dismissing complex theories like Marxism as immoral oversimplifies their arguments.
More from Leo Tolstoy
Aesthetic theories arose one hundred fifty years ago among the wealthy classes of the Christian European world. ...And notwithstanding its obvious insolidity, …
Permalink to quote #73 The good is the everlasting, the pinnacle of our life. ...life is striving towards the good, toward God. The good is the most basic idea... an idea not definab…
Permalink to quote #75 After Plotinus, says Schassler, fifteen centuries passed without the slightest scientific interest for the world of beauty and art. ...In reality, nothing of t…
Permalink to quote #72
Related quotes
Our revolution has made me feel the full force of the axiom that history is fiction and I am convinced that chance and intrigue have produced more heroes than …
Maximilien RobespierreMaximilien Robespierre quote #4 'All morality has been modelled on immorality and to this day has reinstated it at every level. The slave morality is indeed bad: it is still the master morali…
Theodor AdornoTheodor Adorno quote #9 That I wasn't interested in politics or social matters, that's dead right. I was utterly indifferent. After the war and the discovery of the concentration camp…
Ingmar BergmanIngmar Bergman quote #25