Skip to content
quotesby

The crucial question for us is not whether they have a theocratic government. I'd personally prefer not, but I can think of a lot of places where I'd prefer not, like here. But, the question is whether the US will agree to let Iraq alone. That means to make it very clean and explicit, both in word and in action, that the US will withdraw, set a timetable for it, will not influence what goes on in Iraq, will not leave military bases, will let the country go off on its own. I think we also ought to pay massive reparations, but I'll stop short of that. Those are the crucial issues. It's not up to Rumsfeld what kind of government they have, it's up to him to get out.

Noam Chomsky#116

Foreign policyInterventionIraqJusticeOccupationSovereignty

About this quote

What does it mean?
Chomsky states the US should withdraw from Iraq and stop influencing its government, regardless of its political system.
In plain terms
The US should leave Iraq alone and pay reparations instead of controlling its politics.
What can you take from it?
Sovereignty matters more than imposed political systems.

Where it applies

  • foreign policy
  • nation building

Putting it to work

  • supporting withdrawal
  • ending occupation

Questions to consider

  • When is intervention justified?
  • Who decides a nation's government?

Another view

It ignores internal Iraqi conflicts that might require external help.

More from Noam Chomsky

  1. The big debate in Washington is totally pointless. And the media, about whether Bush downgraded terror in order to invade Iraq. There's nothing to debate. He i…

    Permalink to quote #115
  2. I think murdering Iraqi union leaders is criminal, for example. And a lot of what the insurgents have done is criminal. But, you know, you rank the priorities.…

    Permalink to quote #117
  3. It's certainly true that the world is better off without Saddam Hussein, and also without the people who supported him through his worst atrocities, and are no…

    Permalink to quote #114

Related quotes

  1. Iraq is an unjust war. (spoken on the Diane Rehm Show; stated in articles written for NY Times; printed in USA Today)

    Jimmy CarterJimmy Carter quote #10
  2. Any country whose people conduct themselves well can count upon our hearty friendship. If a nation shows that it knows how to act with reasonable efficiency an…

    Theodore RooseveltTheodore Roosevelt quote #16
  3. They intend, if they can, to have an Iraq Americana, but the Iraqi people have decided otherwise.

    George GallowayGeorge Galloway quote #16