I've often been struck by the extensive knowledge that people have of sports, and particularly, their self-confidence in discussing it with 'experts.' While driving, I sometimes turn on radio talk shows on sports, and am always struck by this. People calling in have no hesitation in criticizing the coaches, the judgments of the people running the shows, etc. In contrast, when discussing matters of concern to human lives -- their own and others -- people tend to defer to 'experts,' though for the most part the expert knowledge is no more beyond them than how the local professional sports team should play their next game. That's where the indoctrination comes in: in the intensive training that brings people to feel that they must defer to alleged 'experts' on matters of very direct concern to them, far more so than sports. I do, however, agree that there can be negative aspects to the heavily promoted frenzy on spectator sports, loyalty to the home team, etc. Depends very much on how it is carried out.
About this quote
- What does it mean?
- People are confident discussing sports but defer to experts on life matters. This difference comes from indoctrination to trust authorities on serious issues.
- In plain terms
- We trust ourselves in sports but blindly trust experts on important things.
- What can you take from it?
- Question expert authority on matters affecting your life.
Where it applies
Putting it to work
Questions to consider
- Why trust experts on some things but not others?
- How is confidence built?
Another view
It implies all expert deference is indoctrinated rather than practical.
More from Noam Chomsky
...another thing you sometimes find in non-literate cultures is development of the most extraordinary linguistic systems: often there's tremendous sophisticati…
Permalink to quote #187 Prophet just means intellectual. They were people giving geopolitical analysis, moral lessons, that sort of thing. We call them intellectuals today. There were…
Permalink to quote #189 There's one white powder which is by far the most lethal known, it's called sugar. If you look at the history of imperialism, a lot of it has to do with that. …
Permalink to quote #186
Related quotes
In America, it is sport that is the opiate of the masses.
Russell BakerRussell Baker quote #2 *Get your own entry in an encyclopedia... In the media age, everybody was famous for 15 minutes. In the Wikipedia age, everybody can be an expert in five minut…
Stephen ColbertStephen Colbert quote #6 I don't need Michael Moore to tell me about September 11.
Rudy GiulianiRudy Giuliani quote #7