His focus, almost exclusively, has been on U.S. foreign policy, a narrowness that would exert a conservative influence even for a radical thinker. If urging increased involvement in politics goes against the potentially subversive tide toward less and less involvement, Chomsky's emphasis on statecraft itself gravitates toward acceptance of states. And completely ignoring key areas (such as nature and women, to mention only two), makes him less relevant still. --John Zerzan, 1996 [196]
About this quote
- What does it mean?
- Zerzan criticizes Chomsky for focusing too narrowly on U.S. foreign policy and statecraft, which limits his relevance to broader issues like nature and women.
- In plain terms
- Chomsky's narrow focus on politics and the state makes him less relevant to other important areas.
- What can you take from it?
- Broadening one's focus can increase relevance and impact.
Where it applies
Putting it to work
Questions to consider
- Is narrow focus a strength or weakness?
- What issues are missing from mainstream political analysis?
Another view
Depth in one area can be more valuable than breadth.
More from Noam Chomsky
Those who challenge the 'Right to Lie', as Chomsky describes it, can expect to be met with vilification and distortion. Such vilification campaigns succeed by …
Permalink to quote #214 Chomsky's truly great contribution to the struggle for human freedom is that he has taken what we have been persuaded to believe is an insane idea, a product o…
Permalink to quote #216 [Chomsky's work was] subjected to an ongoing and intense scrutiny for any literal errors or bases of vulnerability, a scrutiny from which establishment experts…
Permalink to quote #213
Related quotes
He is one of those wise philanthropists who in a time of famine would vote for nothing but a supply of toothpicks.
Douglas William JerroldDouglas William Jerrold quote #1 George W. Bush is a man who seems to be the center of his own universe. He seems to have learned little of human nature and even less of human history over his…
Robert ByrdRobert Byrd quote #1 Gradually I began to intellectually reject some of the delusionally influenced lines of thinking which had been characteristic of my orientation. This began, m…
John Forbes NashJohn Forbes Nash quote #1