Skip to content
quotesby

The Americans' very conviction that their goals are good blinds them to the consequences of their acts. To focus on intentions is to prolong a futile clash of inflamed self-righteousness; to focus on behavior and results could get us somewhere. I detect in Professor Chomsky's approach, in his uncomplicated attribution of evil objectives to his foes, in his fondness for abstract principles, in his moral impatience, the mirror image of the very features that both he and I dislike in American foreign policy. To me sanity does not consist of replying to a crusade with an anti-crusade. As scholars and as citizens, we must require and provide discriminating and disciplined reasoning on behalf of our values. --Stanley Hoffmann, March 1969 [207]

Noam Chomsky#226

ChomskyWarEthicsForeign policyBehaviorIntentionReasoning

About this quote

What does it mean?
Hoffmann argues focusing on intentions rather than behavior fuels conflict.
In plain terms
Look at actions not just intentions to resolve conflict.
What can you take from it?
Focus on behavior not just intentions.

Where it applies

  • resolving disputes
  • analyzing policy
  • ethical reasoning

Putting it to work

  • judge by outcomes
  • avoid moral crusades

Questions to consider

  • Should intentions or outcomes matter more?
  • How to avoid crusades in policy?

Another view

Intentions matter in some moral frameworks.

More from Noam Chomsky

  1. The best thing about Chomsky is that he raises the blood pressure anti-Lefties far more than he deserves. Still, Chomsky's about as challenging as Mr. Rogers. …

    Permalink to quote #225
  2. [Noam Chomsky] seems to feel licensed to forget or distort the truth whenever it suits his polemical convenience. He begins as a preacher to the world and ends…

    Permalink to quote #227
  3. He would have us believe that Israel's occupation and harsh actions against the Palestinians, its invasions and undeclared 20-year war on Lebanon, and its armi…

    Permalink to quote #224

Related quotes

  1. He had never disagreed with anyone in his life, no matter how unfairly they may have treated him. He preferred to swallow his tears, suppress his anger and bit…

    Ba JinBa Jin quote #1
  2. It's not their fault if, in the heat Of their transactions, I repeat It's not their fault if vampires meet And gurgle in their spats.

    Mervyn PeakeMervyn Peake quote #9
  3. 'The greatest crime since World War II has been U.S. foreign policy.'

    Ramsey ClarkRamsey Clark quote #9