Just imagine, he says, the policies that such an Iraq would be likely to pursue: 'The Shiite population in the south, where most of Iraq's oil is, would have a predominant influence. They would prefer friendly relations with Shiite Iran.' He wrote those words in January 2006. A year and a half later, the United States tolerates a sovereign, more or less democratic Iraq whose Shiite government is friendly toward Iran. If Bush is pursuing imperialism in Baghdad, it is of a very curious sort. --Jonathan Rauch, September 2, 2007 [240]
About this quote
- What does it mean?
- The author argues that US policy in Iraq inadvertently supported a Shiite-dominated government aligned with Iran, contradicting claims of imperialist intent.
- In plain terms
- US actions in Iraq led to a friendly Shiite government in Iran, which seems odd if the goal was control.
- What can you take from it?
- Outcomes can contradict stated intentions in foreign policy.
Where it applies
Putting it to work
Questions to consider
- Did the US intend this outcome?
- How do we judge imperialist intent?
Another view
The quote relies on specific interpretations of US intent that may be debated.
More from Noam Chomsky
The radicals moved their support, in a peculiar way, to the successor of the USSR too, Putin's Russia. The genocidal war of Russia in Chechnya - far worse than…
Permalink to quote #258 Noam Chomsky: He's really an interventionist - and also completely clueless. --Justin Raimondo, January 18, 2002 [241]
Permalink to quote #260 Chomsky once told a group of people that he himself was 'agnostic' on whether the Holocaust occurred. When professor Robert Nozick, who was part of the group, …
Permalink to quote #257
Related quotes
You know we armed Iraq. I wondered about that too, you know. During the Persian Gulf war, those intelligence reports would come out: 'Iraq: incredible weapons …
Bill HicksBill Hicks quote #7 Iran is a great problem, but not necessarily a great country. In fact, I think it is a very weak country.
Shimon PeresShimon Peres quote #7 'The greatest crime since World War II has been U.S. foreign policy.'
Ramsey ClarkRamsey Clark quote #9