Skip to content
quotesby

The rude, discursive Thinker is the Scholastic (Schoolman Logician). The true Scholastic is a mystical Subtlist; out of logical Atoms he builds his Universe; he annihilates all living Nature, to put an Artifice of Thoughts (Gedankenkunststuck, literally Conjuror's-trick of Thoughts) in its room. His aim is an infinite Automaton. Opposite to him is the rude, intuitive Poet: this is a mystical Macrologist: he hates rules and fixed form; a wild, violent life reigns instead of it in Nature; all is animate, no law; wilfulness and wonder everywhere. He is merely dynamical. Thus does the Philosophic Spirit arise at first, in altogether separate masses. In the second stage of culture these masses begin to come in contact, multifariously enough; and, as in the union of infinite Extremes, the Finite, the Limited arises, so here also arise 'Eclectic Philosophers' without number; the time of misunderstanding begins. The most limited is, in this stage, the most important, the purest Philosopher of the second stage. This class occupies itself wholly with the actual, present world, in the strictest sense. The Philosophers of the first class look down with contempt on those of the second; say, they are a little of everything, and so nothing; hold their views as the results of weakness, as Inconsequentism. On the contrary, the second class, in their turn, pity the first; lay the blame on their visionary enthusiasm, which they say is absurd, even to insanity.

Novalis#42

PhilosophyNaturePoetryReasonCulture

About this quote

What does it mean?
The Scholastic builds a logical machine; the Poet embraces wild nature. Culture unites them into eclectic philosophers.
In plain terms
Logic builds machines; poetry embraces wild nature. They eventually blend.
What can you take from it?
Reason and intuition must meet in culture.

Where it applies

  • intellectual history
  • cultural critique

Putting it to work

  • integrating art and science
  • studying culture

Questions to consider

  • Do logic and intuition mix?
  • What is culture?

Another view

It oversimplifies philosophical traditions.

More from Novalis

  1. Common Logic is the Grammar of the higher Speech, that is, of Thought; it examines merely the relations of ideas to one another, the Mechanics of Thought, the …

    Permalink to quote #41
  2. If on the one hand the Scholastics and Alchemists seem to be utterly at variance, and the Eclectics on the other hand quite at one, yet, strictly examined, it …

    Permalink to quote #43
  3. The waking man looks without fear at this offspring of his lawless Imagination; for he knows that they are but vain Spectres of his weakness. He feels himself …

    Permalink to quote #40

Related quotes

  1. Death is an angel with two faces: To us he turns A face of terror, blighting all things fair; The other burns With glory of the stars, and love is there.

    Theodore Chickering WilliamsTheodore Chickering Williams quote #2
  2. Ach, die Garten bist du, ach, ich sah sie mit solcher Hoffnung. Ein offenes Fenster im Landhaus-, und du tratest beinahe mir nachdenklich heran. Gassen fand ic…

    Rainer Maria RilkeRainer Maria Rilke quote #3
  3. Harddwas teg a'm anrhegai, Hylaw wr mawr hael yw'r Mai. Anfones ym iawn fwnai, Glas defyll glan mwyngyll Mai. Ffloringod brig ni'm digiai, Fflwr-dy-lis gyfoeth…

    Dafydd ap GwilymDafydd ap Gwilym quote #9