Xenophon, too, does not appear to have been very friendlily disposed towards him: and accordingly they have, as if in rivalry of one another, both written books with the same title, the Banquet, the Defence of Socrates, Moral Reminiscences. Then, too, the one wrote the Cyropaedia and the other a book on Politics ; and Plato in his Laws says, that the Cyropaedia is a mere romance, for that Cyrus was not such a person as he is described in that book. And though they both speak so much of Socrates, neither of them ever mentions the other, except that Xenophon once speaks of Plato in the third book of his Reminiscences.
About this quote
- What does it mean?
- Xenophon and Plato wrote works with similar titles but disagreed on content, such as Plato calling Xenophon's Cyropaedia a romance, and they rarely mentioned each other despite both writing about Socrates.
- In plain terms
- Xenophon and Plato wrote similar books but criticized each other and hardly mentioned one another.
- What can you take from it?
- Rivals can share subjects yet compete on how they portray them.
Where it applies
Putting it to work
Questions to consider
- How do rivals shape each other's work?
- Why avoid mentioning peers?
Another view
Their silence might reflect politeness rather than rivalry.
More from Plato
He was the first author who wrote treatises in the form of dialogues ... And as he argued against almost every one who had lived before his time, it is often a…
Permalink to quote #73 What is Plato, but Moses speaking in Attic Greek?
Permalink to quote #75 Here, first of all men for pure justice famed, And moral virtue, Aristocles lies; And if there e'er has lived one truly wise, This man was wiser still; too gre…
Permalink to quote #72
Related quotes
Even of old the Christian world, so bitterly antagonistic to any ideas not specifically contained in their creeds and dogmas, made an exception in Socrates' ca…
Edith HamiltonEdith Hamilton quote #3 The use of this feigned history hath been to give some shadow of satisfaction to the mind of man in those points wherein the nature of things doth deny it, the…
Francis BaconFrancis Bacon quote #19 When Socrates and his two great disciples composed a system of rational ethics they were hardly proposing practical legislation for mankind...They were merely …
George SantayanaGeorge Santayana quote #26